Do Detectives Think? (1927)

Do Detectives Think? Poster

An escaped convict is out to kill the judge who sentenced him. Two inept detectives are hired to guard the judge.

Introduction
"Do Detectives Think?" is a quiet short comedy film from 1927 directed by Fred Guiol and produced by the legendary Hal Roach Studios. The movie includes the renowned duo Laurel and Hardy, who would later on become one of the most popular funny teams in cinema history. While this was not the official beginning of their collaboration, it is one of the earliest movies where they appear together, foreshadowing their potential as a comedic pair. The movie centers around a set of inefficient detectives employed to secure a judge from a murderous convict.

Plot Overview
The film opens with an intense found guilty, "The Tipton Slasher" (played by Noah Young), being sentenced to prison by Judge Foozle (played by James Finlayson). Swearing vengeance, the Slasher leaves from jail and sets out to fulfill his vow, prompting the judge to look for protection. The judge employs the detective agency of "Sherlock Jr. and Dr. Watts" to guarantee his security.

Go into the bumbling detective group: Ferdinand Finkleberry, played by Stan Laurel, and his partner Sherlock Pinkham, played by Oliver Hardy. Donning exaggerated disguises to entertain the audience, Laurel and Hardy are tasked with safeguarding Judge Foozle from potential damage. Particular of their early work, the set takes part in a series of slapstick gags and miscommunications, as they have a hard time to adapt to their functions as protectors.

Comical Antics
Audiences witness Laurel and Hardy engage in limitless shenanigans, consisting of Laurel misinterpreting a safe visitor for the Slasher and Hardy's arrogant efforts to appear positive and in control. The dynamic in between the investigators unfolds through visual gags and situational funny, much of which includes the abuse of their investigator gadgets. These gags are amplified by Hardy's well-known exasperated looks and Laurel's sheepish, confused expressions.

As the events progress, the Slasher handles to penetrate the judge's home camouflaged as a suit of armor, while Laurel and Hardy's characters stay blissfully unaware of the approaching threat. In a series of comical close calls and incorrect identities, the detectives continuously prevent conflict with the Slasher, while Judge Foozle grows increasingly on edge.

Climax and Resolution
The climax appears when the fit of armor comes to life, resulting in a chaotic scramble as the Slasher finally exposes himself and chases his designated victims through your home. Laurel and Hardy prove themselves to be more fortunate than competent when they unintentionally succeed in suppressing the Slasher through a series of serendipitous mishaps.

The film concludes as order is restored, and the investigators proudly take credit for recording the left found guilty, despite their absence of genuine investigator prowess. The slapstick humor and perfect timing that would become Laurel and Hardy's hallmark are on complete display screen as the film concludes with the pledge of more laughter in the duo's future experiences.

Legacy and Influence
"Do Detectives Think?" has earned its place in cinematic history as one of the lots of stepping stones leading to the facility of Laurel and Hardy as the iconic comical duo they ultimately became. While not a groundbreaking film compared to their later work, it showcases the initial trigger of on-screen chemistry in between Laurel and Hardy. Their apparent comedic rhythm, the physical comedy, and the effective use of overstated situations and characters ended up being a formula they would refine and ideal for many years to come.

As a piece of the late quiet movie period, "Do Detectives Think?" stands as a charming example of early screen comedy and the ageless appeal of Laurel and Hardy's humor, as they stumbled their way into the hearts of audiences around the globe.

Top Cast

  • Stan Laurel (small)
    Stan Laurel
    Ferdinand Finkleberry
  • Oliver Hardy (small)
    Oliver Hardy
    Sherlock Pinkham
  • James Finlayson (small)
    James Finlayson
    Judge Foozle
  • Viola Richard (small)
    Viola Richard
    Mrs. Foozle
  • Noah Young (small)
    Noah Young
    The Tipton Slasher
  • Frank Brownlee
    Detective agency boss
  • Chester A. Bachman (small)
    Chester A. Bachman
    Officer
  • Wilson Benge (small)
    Wilson Benge
    Butler attacked by Slasher
  • Will Stanton (small)
    Will Stanton
    Killer's pal
  • Charley Young
    Juror