In the Good Old Summertime (1949)

In the Good Old Summertime Poster

Two co-workers in a music shop dislike one another during business hours but unwittingly carry on an anonymous romance through the mail.

Introduction to "In the Good Old Summertime"
"In the Good Old Summertime" is a 1949 American musical movie directed by Robert Z. Leonard. The movie stars Judy Garland, Van Johnson, and S.Z. Sakall and is a musical adaptation of the Hungarian play "Parfumerie" by Miklós László. The plot of the film follows the core story of the play, which was later adapted into other movies and programs, most especially "The Shop Around the Corner" and the Tom Hanks-Meg Ryan film "You've Got Mail". Embed In 1900s Chicago, the film uses the fond memories of the turn-of-the-century period to produce a lovely and romantic environment.

Plot Summary of "In the Good Old Summertime"
The story revolves around 2 workers, Andrew Larkin (Van Johnson) and Veronica Fisher (Judy Garland), operating at a music shop owned by Otto Oberkugen (S.Z. Sakall). Andrew and Veronica do not get along in person; nevertheless, they are unconsciously falling for each other through anonymous letters they exchange as pen pals. The plot uses this significant irony to produce tension and humor, as numerous misconceptions and the characters' obliviousness to each other's identities result in comedic situations.

As their correspondence continues and their romance blooms in composing, their real-life relationship remains laden with competition and petty arguments, especially concerning sales techniques and their standing with Mr. Oberkugen at the shop. The story intensifies when Andrew plans to lastly meet his pen friend at a local café, not recognizing he's about to discover that the woman of his dreams is actually Veronica, the co-worker with whom he's constantly at odds.

Musical and Romantic Elements
The musical measurement of "In the Good Old Summertime" adds charm to the narrative as the characters reveal their feelings and advance the story through song. Judy Garland, in particular, shines in her musical numbers, showcasing her singing skill and adding depth to her portrayal of Veronica. The movie consists of standards like the titular "In the Good Old Summertime" and newer structures, which are flawlessly integrated into the story.

Romance is a central theme as both Andrew and Veronica navigate their feelings for their mysterious letter writer while challenging each other in their day-to-day encounters. Similar to many romantic funnies, much of the satisfaction originates from the audience's anticipation of the minute when the characters' dual identities will be revealed and their true feelings will be acknowledged.

Themes and Reception
The title "In the Good Old Summertime" suggests a yearning for what was viewed as an easier, more genteel period, which the movie represents with its vibrant sets, period outfits, and wholesome representation of courtship. It conjures up themes of love, miscommunication, and the social changes of the period.

Critically, the movie was popular upon its release. The chemistry in between Garland and Johnson was applauded, as was the light-hearted and family-friendly nature of the story. The film was a ticket office success, further cementing Judy Garland's status as one of Hollywood's leading musical stars.

Conclusion and Legacy of the Film
"In the Good Old Summertime" sustains as a classic musical and romantic comedy, kept in mind for its sentimental appeal and remarkable performances. The movie is not only substantial as a part of Judy Garland's illustrious profession but also as a representation of the long-lasting appeal of romantic misadventures set to music. Its story continues to resonate with audiences even today, as evidenced by its numerous adaptations, highlighting the universal appeal of finding love in the most unexpected places. Its concluding scene, with the leads lastly joining in harmony both musically and romantically, provides a gratifying culmination to a work that endearingly stimulates the simplicity and love of a bygone period.

Top Cast

  • Judy Garland (small)
    Judy Garland
    Veronica Fisher
  • Van Johnson (small)
    Van Johnson
    Andrew Delby Larkin
  • S.Z. Sakall (small)
    S.Z. Sakall
    Otto Oberkugen
  • Spring Byington (small)
    Spring Byington
    Nellie Burke
  • Clinton Sundberg (small)
    Clinton Sundberg
    Rudy Hansen
  • Buster Keaton (small)
    Buster Keaton
    Hickey
  • Marcia Van Dyke (small)
    Marcia Van Dyke
    Louise Parkson
  • Lillian Bronson (small)
    Lillian Bronson
    Aunt Addie
  • John Alban
    Audience Member (uncredited)
  • Bette Arlen
    Girl (uncredited)
  • William Bailey (small)
    William Bailey
    Supper Club Patron (uncredited)