It's Not All True (1986)

It's Not All True Poster
Original Title: Nem Tudo é Verdade

Orson Welles goes to Brazil to shoot his documentary It's All True.

Introduction
"It's Not All True" is a 1986 Brazilian movie that intertwines imaginary components with historic facts, producing an unique blend of documentary and drama. Directed by the renowned filmmaker Rogério Sganzerla, the movie examines the facts and misconceptions surrounding Orson Welles's unfortunate trip to Brazil in 1942. During that journey, Welles was expected to deal with a movie called "It's All True", which was never ever completed. Sganzerla's "It's Not All True" acts as a retrospective and a rebuilt vision of what might have been.

Plot Overview
The movie opens by depicting the cultural and political atmosphere of Brazil in the 1940s, offering a backdrop to Welles's journey. Welles, played by actor José Lewgoy, gets here with grand aspirations to produce a Pan-American movie that would reinforce the ties in between North and South America, as part of the Good Neighbor policy. The original task included 4 sectors: "My Friend Bonito", "The Story of Samba", "Carnival", and "Jangadeiros", each exploring different aspects of Latin American life and folklore.

As "It's Not All True" progresses, the focus moves to the actual process of shooting "It's All True" and the challenges Welles faced. From the beginning, difficulties afflict the project as Welles struggles with language barriers, cultural misunderstandings, financial concerns, and technical obstacles. His vision encounters resistance from the Hollywood studio in addition to unpredicted logistical barriers.

The Jangadeiros Segment
One of the main aspects that "It's Not All True" explores is the "Jangadeiros" segment of Welles's unfinished project. It is based on the real story of four anglers, or "jangadeiros," who, in an effort to protest versus unfair labor practices, sailed over 1,500 miles on a raft from the state of Ceará to Rio de Janeiro. Sganzerla weaves this story into his film to underline the tragic outcome of these fishermen, whose plight Welles endeavored to record and give worldwide attention. Yet, as Sganzerla digs much deeper, he reveals the layers of intricacy and contradiction that eventually caused the failure of "It's All True".

Creative Style and Structure
"It's Not All True" is characterized by its speculative method to storytelling. Sganzerla utilizes a mix of archival video, reenactments, and interviews with those who were included with Welles during his time in Brazil. This amalgamated style of documentary filmmaking invites the audience to question the nature of reality and fabrication in the retelling of historical occasions. The film contrasts the depiction of Welles's utopian vision with the extreme truths that caused the collapse of the original job.

Themes and Analysis
At its core, "It's Not All True" is an exploration of the interaction in between movie theater, politics, and reality. It examines the function of a filmmaker as a cultural ambassador and the fundamental challenges that come with attempting to cross-cultural borders and inform stories that might not be one's own. Through this story, Sganzerla also comments on the impact of Hollywood on world movie theater and the power dynamics at play.

Tradition and Conclusion
"It's Not All True" not only pays homage to an overlooked piece of cinematic history however also reopens the discussion about the power of storytelling and who gets to tell which stories. Sganzerla's film stands as a thought-provoking piece, causing viewers to reflect upon the unfinished tradition of Orson Welles in Brazil and the implications of grand artistic endeavours that encounter immutable socioeconomic restrictions. Though less known, "It's Not All True" is a cinematic essay of significant significance for its crucial look at filmmaking, the function of the artist, and the evasive nature of fact.

Top Cast

  • Arrigo Barnabé (small)
    Arrigo Barnabé
    Orson Welles
  • Grande Otelo (small)
    Grande Otelo
    Himself
  • Orson Welles (small)
    Orson Welles
    Himself (archive footage)
  • Helena Ignez (small)
    Helena Ignez
  • Nina de Pádua (small)
    Nina de Pádua
  • Abrahão Farc
  • Luiz Motta
    Narração
  • Guará Rodrigues (small)
    Guará Rodrigues
  • Mário Cravo Junior
  • Otávio Terceiro
  • Nonato Freire