Should Tall Men Marry? (1928)

Should Tall Men Marry? Poster

This western comedy is about rancher Finlayson's beautiful daughter, Martha Sleeper, who refuses to marry the bad guy and how Jimmy and dimwitted cowhand Stan bumble their way into a successful defense of her and the ranch.

Introduction
"Should Tall Men Marry?" is a comedy quiet movie launched in 1928. Produced under the banner of Hal Roach Studios and directed by Louis J. Gasnier, it stars a notable star of the silent era - Stan Laurel. While it is a short movie, lasting just 20 minutes, it ensures a hearty laugh fest with its remarkably written comic sequences.

Characters
Stan Laurel, the main character, deftly essays the role of Stan, a secret service agent sent out in camouflage. Olive Borden plays the function of Stan's love interest named Lola. Other important characters consist of Frank Brownlee as Sheriff Martin, Wilson Benge as the Butler, and Tiny Sanford as the Cook.

Plot
The film unfolds with Stan on an objective as a secret service representative looking for and nab a gang of counterfeiters in a Western town. He poses as a safe visitor but ends up being suspicious to the local sheriff due to his odd habits. Meanwhile, Stan succumbs to the gorgeous Lola who has no concept about his secret objective.

Comic Elements
Throughout the film, the director has deftly used comical aspects. Stan Laurel's theatrical comedic design is the bedrock of the film's humor. His slapstick minutes, exaggerated reactions, and facial expressions stimulate laughter. For example, when Stan, after munching on a mouthful of bullets rather of beans, has to deal with the effects of popping the bullets due to the heat produced in his body, viewers are left in splits.

Love, Suspense, and Counterfeiters
While comedy is a dominant part of the film, the subtle romantic subplot in between Stan and Lola adds heat and depth to the narrative. The plot thickens when it's revealed that Lola's uncle is the counterfeiter Stan is attempting to catch. The various problems and humorous scenarios occurring from this circumstance are well-incorporated, keeping the audience on the edge of their seats, while concurrently doubling up in laughter.

Humorous Climax
In the climax of the film, Stan mistakenly discovers proof against Lola's uncle. Here, comedy, thriller, and romance come together in a memorable funny finale. Stan confronts the criminals camouflaged as a ghost after stumbling upon phosphorous paint. The counterfeiters, frightened out of their wits, confess to their criminal offenses, and Lola falls in love with Stan for his bravery.

Conclusion
"Should Tall Men Marry?" is an outstanding example of Laurel and Hardy-style comedy - filled with physical humor, absurd situations, and fantastic timing. While not neglecting the romantic storyline, the film pulls out all the stops to ensure laughter, presenting a mix of comedy, romance, and suspense. Despite being a quiet film, the wit and humor of this comedy timeless transcend the barriers of time and language. Stan Laurel's fantastic performance makes the film a must-watch for funny enthusiasts, standing as a testament to the classic appeal of silent-era funny.

Top Cast

  • James Finlayson (small)
    James Finlayson
    Joe Skittle
  • Martha Sleeper (small)
    Martha Sleeper
    Martha Skittle
  • Theodore von Eltz (small)
    Theodore von Eltz
    Teddy
  • Stuart Holmes (small)
    Stuart Holmes
    Snake-tail Sharkey
  • Stan Laurel (small)
    Stan Laurel
    Texas Tommy