The Sleepwalker Killing (1997)

The Sleepwalker Killing Poster

Mark Schall kills his mother-in-law and wounds his father-in-law in the middle of the night, then turns himself in. He claims, however, that he cannot remember the crime itself. His defense team finds evidence that suggests the crimes were committed while Mark was sleep walking. They build their defense around this theory.

Film Background

"The Sleepwalker Killing" is a 1997 made-for-television movie directed by John Cosgrove. The movie is based on a real story and narrates the trial of Mark Schall, who eliminated his mother-in-law while sleepwalking. The film stars Hilary Swank as Mark's spouse Lauren Schall, Jeffrey Nordling as Mark Schall, and Charles Esten as Detective Brogan.

The Plot
Mark Schall is the protagonist of the film. Living an apparently normal life as a devoted husband to Lauren, Mark is faced with a scary truth when he is implicated of brutally killing his mother-in-law while sleepwalking. The story shifts in between his life after the event and the events leading up to it.

One night, Mark enters into their cooking area and shoots his mother-in-law dead while in a state of apparent unconsciousness. Lauren, upon hearing the gunshot, wakes up and discovers Mark standing over her dead mom with a gun in his hand. Lauren believes Mark's claim that he was sleepwalking during the occurrence, however, the rest of her household is doubtful.

Examination and Trial
The murder case brings in Detective Brogan's attention who is initially determined about Mark's guilt. As he investigates the case, he discovers a history of sleepwalking occurrences in Mark's family, leading him to question if Mark indeed devoted the murder unconsciously.

The trial sparks a significant dispute about whether the act was premeditated or an outcome of parasomnia, a sleep condition causing irregular habits throughout sleep. The defense attorney argues for Mark's innocence, basing his defense on the medical condition of sleepwalking and bringing forth proof of past incidents.

Court Proceedings
During the court proceedings, the defense counsel produces professional witnesses to affirm on the nature of sleep conditions, who verify that individuals can undoubtedly commit violent acts while asleep, without being aware of their actions. On the other hand, the prosecution maintains the position that Mark killed his mother-in-law intentionally and utilizes an old grudge against the mother-in-law as the intention.

Last Verdict
Despite the strong arguments put forth by the prosecuting group and public belief versus him, Mark is acquitted of the charges by the jury, accepting the argument that he committed the murder while sleepwalking. The verdict shocks numerous, and Mark is launched.

Conclusion
"The Sleepwalker Killing" is a strong and daring piece of film, dramatizing a real-life legal case known as the "sleepwalking defense". While it does paint a precise photo of the disease's severity, the film also exposes the complexity of the justice system and the individual predispositions that can influence its outcome. The movie leaves the audience to contemplate whether Mark really was a victim of his sleep disorder or whether he found a creative method to exploit the legal system. Despite leaving some ambiguity on Mark's real status, the movie does an extensive job in presenting the case and its complexities. It acts as a gripping and thought-provoking look for anyone thinking about real criminal activity and the complexities of humanity.

Top Cast

  • Hilary Swank (small)
    Hilary Swank
    Lauren Schall
  • Jeffrey Nordling (small)
    Jeffrey Nordling
    Det. Lloyd Boyko
  • Charles Esten (small)
    Charles Esten
    Mark Schall
  • Sean Murray (small)
    Sean Murray
    Christopher Lane
  • Marisa Coughlan (small)
    Marisa Coughlan
    Tanya Lane