"I look for those moments that are "gee whiz" moments. There's some "gee whiz" stories in our show, and they can't be written like A-1 in the Times. They have to be written more like Page 6 in the Post"

Shepard Smith is referring to the type of stories he searches for when creating material for his show. He is recommending that the stories he tries to find are more interesting and entertaining than the typical newspaper article that are composed in a more severe and official way. He is recommending that the stories he searches for should be composed more like the stories discovered in the New York Post's Page 6, which are frequently more gossipy and entertaining than the stories discovered in the New York Times' A-1 section. He is searching for stories that will amaze and delight viewers, stories that will make them say "gee whiz". He is searching for stories that will record the attention of viewers and make them wish to tune in to his show.