"A belief which leaves no place for doubt is not a belief; it is a superstition"
About this Quote
Certainty is the oldest trick in the book: it feels like strength, but it’s usually just fear in a pressed suit. Bergamin’s line turns that discomfort into a litmus test. A belief that cannot tolerate doubt isn’t conviction sharpened to a point; it’s conviction fossilized. By redefining “no doubt” as “superstition,” he flips the usual hierarchy. We tend to treat superstition as a primitive cousin of faith and belief as the mature, rational option. Bergamin argues the opposite: the moment belief demands total immunity from questioning, it stops being a living commitment and becomes magical thinking with better branding.
The subtext is political as much as spiritual. Bergamin wrote through Spain’s most punishing century: civil war, authoritarianism, and an official culture that prized unanimity. In those environments, doubt isn’t a private mood; it’s a civic threat. The line reads like a quiet act of resistance against any system - religious, ideological, nationalist - that equates loyalty with intellectual surrender. “Leaves no place” matters: it suggests architecture, an entire mental room designed to keep doubt out, like boarding up windows to prevent unwanted light.
What makes the aphorism work is its paradoxical rigor. It doesn’t praise doubt as fashionable skepticism; it insists doubt is the proof that belief is real. A belief worth having has edges that can be tested. If it can’t survive contact with uncertainty, it’s not faith. It’s an incantation.
The subtext is political as much as spiritual. Bergamin wrote through Spain’s most punishing century: civil war, authoritarianism, and an official culture that prized unanimity. In those environments, doubt isn’t a private mood; it’s a civic threat. The line reads like a quiet act of resistance against any system - religious, ideological, nationalist - that equates loyalty with intellectual surrender. “Leaves no place” matters: it suggests architecture, an entire mental room designed to keep doubt out, like boarding up windows to prevent unwanted light.
What makes the aphorism work is its paradoxical rigor. It doesn’t praise doubt as fashionable skepticism; it insists doubt is the proof that belief is real. A belief worth having has edges that can be tested. If it can’t survive contact with uncertainty, it’s not faith. It’s an incantation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Jose
Add to List
