"A casual stroll through the lunatic asylum shows that faith does not prove anything"
About this Quote
Nietzsche doesn’t bother refuting faith with syllogisms; he drags it through an institution. The “casual stroll” is the sneer: a tourist’s pace through other people’s catastrophe, delivered with the offhand confidence of someone who thinks the evidence is too obvious to dignify with solemnity. Then comes the punchline: if the asylum is full of people who believe with total certainty, then certainty can’t be your yardstick for truth. Faith may feel like proof from the inside. From the outside, it’s just intensity.
The subtext is less “religion makes you crazy” than “conviction is cheap.” Nietzsche is attacking an epistemological shortcut: the move where someone points to sincerity, fervor, or inner experience and calls it verification. The asylum functions as an ugly control group. Delusion also arrives with feelings of revelation, grand purpose, absolute meaning. If those psychological sensations can accompany obvious falsehoods, then their presence in religion (or any ideology) can’t carry argumentative weight.
Context matters: late 19th-century Europe is busy laundering Christian morality into “common sense,” while psychiatry is emerging as a new authority sorting belief into normal and pathological. Nietzsche, forever allergic to herd comfort, exploits that shift. He isn’t granting science moral superiority; he’s using the modern spectacle of madness to expose how easily humans mistake need for knowledge. The line’s nastiness is part of its mechanism: it shocks the reader out of reverence, making faith look less like a noble exception and more like one more human strategy for refusing uncertainty.
The subtext is less “religion makes you crazy” than “conviction is cheap.” Nietzsche is attacking an epistemological shortcut: the move where someone points to sincerity, fervor, or inner experience and calls it verification. The asylum functions as an ugly control group. Delusion also arrives with feelings of revelation, grand purpose, absolute meaning. If those psychological sensations can accompany obvious falsehoods, then their presence in religion (or any ideology) can’t carry argumentative weight.
Context matters: late 19th-century Europe is busy laundering Christian morality into “common sense,” while psychiatry is emerging as a new authority sorting belief into normal and pathological. Nietzsche, forever allergic to herd comfort, exploits that shift. He isn’t granting science moral superiority; he’s using the modern spectacle of madness to expose how easily humans mistake need for knowledge. The line’s nastiness is part of its mechanism: it shocks the reader out of reverence, making faith look less like a noble exception and more like one more human strategy for refusing uncertainty.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Friedrich
Add to List








