"A cloud is made of billows upon billows upon billows that look like clouds. As you come closer to a cloud you don't get something smooth, but irregularities at a smaller scale"
About this Quote
Mandelbrot is doing something sly here: he takes a word that sounds like a children’s-book noun, “cloud,” and uses it to indict an entire aesthetic of “smoothness” that dominated classical math and the way modern institutions model the world. The sentence is built like a zoom lens. “Billows upon billows upon billows” isn’t just description; it’s a rhythm that mimics recursion, the feeling of being pulled inward without ever arriving at a final, clean edge. The repetition does the work of persuasion: you’re not being told an abstract theorem, you’re being made to experience scale.
The intent is polemical as much as poetic. Mandelbrot is arguing that nature isn’t an exception to mathematics; it’s an exception to a certain kind of mathematics, the kind that prefers idealized lines, spheres, and frictionless planes. The subtext is a rebuke to the comforting fantasy that closer inspection yields clarity. In many systems - coastlines, markets, lungs, turbulence - magnification reveals more complexity, not less. “You don’t get something smooth” is a quiet slap at the expectation that reality becomes more well-behaved when you increase resolution.
Context matters: Mandelbrot’s fractal geometry emerged in the late 20th century alongside new computational power, which made it possible to see and generate structures defined by self-similarity. He’s also speaking to applied arrogance: policy, finance, and engineering often bank on simplified models. The cloud is his Trojan horse, smuggling in a worldview where irregularity isn’t noise - it’s the signal.
The intent is polemical as much as poetic. Mandelbrot is arguing that nature isn’t an exception to mathematics; it’s an exception to a certain kind of mathematics, the kind that prefers idealized lines, spheres, and frictionless planes. The subtext is a rebuke to the comforting fantasy that closer inspection yields clarity. In many systems - coastlines, markets, lungs, turbulence - magnification reveals more complexity, not less. “You don’t get something smooth” is a quiet slap at the expectation that reality becomes more well-behaved when you increase resolution.
Context matters: Mandelbrot’s fractal geometry emerged in the late 20th century alongside new computational power, which made it possible to see and generate structures defined by self-similarity. He’s also speaking to applied arrogance: policy, finance, and engineering often bank on simplified models. The cloud is his Trojan horse, smuggling in a worldview where irregularity isn’t noise - it’s the signal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|
More Quotes by Benoit
Add to List











