"A commencement is a time of joy. It is also a time of melancholy. But then again, so is life"
About this Quote
Tsongas’s line lands because it refuses the ceremonial lie commencement speeches are built to tell: that the future is clean, upward, and newly minted. He starts with the expected script - joy - then immediately undercuts it with melancholy, not as a mood-killer but as a more honest accounting. The pivot is simple, almost conversational, yet politically savvy: he gives graduates permission to feel ambivalence without sounding bleak. In a setting engineered for certainty, he sneaks in complexity.
The final clause, “But then again, so is life,” does the real work. It collapses the inflated pageantry of graduation into the everyday, shrinking the distance between this “special” day and the ordinary days that follow. That move is a kind of rhetorical inoculation against nostalgia and triumphalism. Tsongas isn’t just describing mixed emotions; he’s training an audience to see them as normal rather than as evidence of personal failure.
Context matters. Tsongas was a politician whose public story included both ambition and fragility - most notably his well-known battle with cancer, which gave his optimism a harder edge than typical civic uplift. Read through that lens, the sentence is less a greeting-card aphorism than a measured insistence on emotional realism. The subtext: adulthood isn’t choosing between celebration and sorrow; it’s learning to carry both without being immobilized by either.
The final clause, “But then again, so is life,” does the real work. It collapses the inflated pageantry of graduation into the everyday, shrinking the distance between this “special” day and the ordinary days that follow. That move is a kind of rhetorical inoculation against nostalgia and triumphalism. Tsongas isn’t just describing mixed emotions; he’s training an audience to see them as normal rather than as evidence of personal failure.
Context matters. Tsongas was a politician whose public story included both ambition and fragility - most notably his well-known battle with cancer, which gave his optimism a harder edge than typical civic uplift. Read through that lens, the sentence is less a greeting-card aphorism than a measured insistence on emotional realism. The subtext: adulthood isn’t choosing between celebration and sorrow; it’s learning to carry both without being immobilized by either.
Quote Details
| Topic | Graduation |
|---|
More Quotes by Paul
Add to List




