"A conventional good read is usually a bad read, a relaxing bath in what we know already. A true good read is surely an act of innovative creation in which we, the readers, become conspirators"
About this Quote
Birrell’s jab lands because it flatters and scolds in the same breath. The “conventional good read” isn’t condemned for being incompetent; it’s condemned for being competent at comfort. Calling it “a relaxing bath” makes the critique tactile: the book as warm water, familiarity as sedation. The target is a culture that praises readability the way it praises good manners - smoothness mistaken for depth, ease mistaken for value.
His sharper move is shifting the burden of artistry. A “true good read” isn’t just a masterfully made object delivered to a passive consumer; it’s “an act of innovative creation” that happens between text and mind. That phrase quietly reassigns authorship: reading becomes a co-production. When Birrell says readers “become conspirators,” he chooses a morally charged metaphor. Conspiracy implies secrecy, risk, a shared plan against the official story. The subtext is that great books recruit you; they don’t soothe you. They make you complicit in new meanings, new forms, sometimes even new heresies.
Context matters: Birrell writes from a late-Victorian/early-modern moment when the novel is both mass entertainment and a testing ground for aesthetic experimentation. His suspicion of the “conventional” reads like an early warning about the marketplace’s preference for the familiar. He’s not arguing against pleasure; he’s arguing against pleasure that leaves no residue. The best reading, for Birrell, changes the reader’s operating system - and does it by making them feel, thrillingly, like an accomplice.
His sharper move is shifting the burden of artistry. A “true good read” isn’t just a masterfully made object delivered to a passive consumer; it’s “an act of innovative creation” that happens between text and mind. That phrase quietly reassigns authorship: reading becomes a co-production. When Birrell says readers “become conspirators,” he chooses a morally charged metaphor. Conspiracy implies secrecy, risk, a shared plan against the official story. The subtext is that great books recruit you; they don’t soothe you. They make you complicit in new meanings, new forms, sometimes even new heresies.
Context matters: Birrell writes from a late-Victorian/early-modern moment when the novel is both mass entertainment and a testing ground for aesthetic experimentation. His suspicion of the “conventional” reads like an early warning about the marketplace’s preference for the familiar. He’s not arguing against pleasure; he’s arguing against pleasure that leaves no residue. The best reading, for Birrell, changes the reader’s operating system - and does it by making them feel, thrillingly, like an accomplice.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Augustine
Add to List
