"A deception that elevates us is dearer than a host of low truths"
About this Quote
A lie that makes the spirit stand taller can feel more vital than a pile of dreary facts. The opposition is vertical: elevation versus lowness. Marina Tsvetaeva lived by that axis. Her poetry reaches up, away from the flatness of mere correctness toward intensity, myth, and the absolute. The line wagers that human beings need more than accuracy; they need nourishment for their striving. A single luminous illusion can summon courage, fidelity, or love, while countless small truths can reduce life to inventory, gossip, and resignation.
The word deception unsettles, and rightly so. It suggests moral risk. Yet for Tsvetaeva, raised in the convulsions of the Russian Silver Age and scattered by revolution and exile, factual truth often arrived as brutality: shortages, denunciations, betrayals. She did not deny reality, but insisted that art and love have their own truth, one that does not always coincide with the ledger. The poet makes a world by intensifying it. Call that deception if you must; its value lies in what it awakens. A myth that elevates can bind a soul to its noblest capacities in a way no catalog of low truths can.
This is not a defense of propaganda or self-serving lies. Tsvetaeva feared the mediocrity of useful falsehoods not anchored in conscience. The elevation she honors is existential, not political: the surge that comes from believing in a destiny, a beloved, a calling. Like Plato’s noble lie or Nietzsche’s life-preserving illusions, the claim is that human flourishing sometimes depends on fictions that reveal a higher order of truth: meaning. The ethical test is upwardness. If the deception enlarges generosity, courage, or artistic fire, it is dear; if it shrinks the self into conformity or cynicism, it is base.
Tsvetaeva’s aphorism challenges a culture hooked on fact-checks but starved of purpose. Facts matter. Without a reason to live by them, they become low truths. The soul needs altitude as well as accuracy.
The word deception unsettles, and rightly so. It suggests moral risk. Yet for Tsvetaeva, raised in the convulsions of the Russian Silver Age and scattered by revolution and exile, factual truth often arrived as brutality: shortages, denunciations, betrayals. She did not deny reality, but insisted that art and love have their own truth, one that does not always coincide with the ledger. The poet makes a world by intensifying it. Call that deception if you must; its value lies in what it awakens. A myth that elevates can bind a soul to its noblest capacities in a way no catalog of low truths can.
This is not a defense of propaganda or self-serving lies. Tsvetaeva feared the mediocrity of useful falsehoods not anchored in conscience. The elevation she honors is existential, not political: the surge that comes from believing in a destiny, a beloved, a calling. Like Plato’s noble lie or Nietzsche’s life-preserving illusions, the claim is that human flourishing sometimes depends on fictions that reveal a higher order of truth: meaning. The ethical test is upwardness. If the deception enlarges generosity, courage, or artistic fire, it is dear; if it shrinks the self into conformity or cynicism, it is base.
Tsvetaeva’s aphorism challenges a culture hooked on fact-checks but starved of purpose. Facts matter. Without a reason to live by them, they become low truths. The soul needs altitude as well as accuracy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Marina
Add to List
