"A demagogue is a person with whom we disagree as to which gang should mismanage the country"
About this Quote
Marquis lands the punch by pretending to offer a definition, then smuggling in an indictment. “A demagogue” isn’t described as a frothing spellbinder or a threat to democracy; he’s reduced to a partisan inconvenience, “a person with whom we disagree.” The sting is that the insult is exposed as tribal shorthand, not moral diagnosis. Marquis is less interested in the demagogue than in the audience that needs one: voters and pundits who treat politics like rival street crews, only with better stationery.
The second half twists the knife: “which gang should mismanage the country.” Not govern, lead, or reform - mismanage. Marquis collapses lofty civic rhetoric into the low expectation that whoever wins will bungle things anyway. That cynicism reads like a 1920s newsroom posture: the age of machine politics, patronage, scandal, and a press that had seen enough backroom dealing to distrust every banner waved in public. His journalist’s eye spots the continuity beneath the costume changes.
Subtextually, it’s also a critique of how “demagogue” functions as a socially acceptable way to say “the other team is illegitimate.” Marquis suggests we don’t deploy the term to defend institutions; we deploy it to defend our gang’s claim to the steering wheel. The joke works because it’s bleakly familiar: politics as a rotating cast of managers who disappoint, while citizens mistake their disappointment for discernment. Marquis doesn’t absolve the demagogue; he implicates the whole ecosystem that manufactures him.
The second half twists the knife: “which gang should mismanage the country.” Not govern, lead, or reform - mismanage. Marquis collapses lofty civic rhetoric into the low expectation that whoever wins will bungle things anyway. That cynicism reads like a 1920s newsroom posture: the age of machine politics, patronage, scandal, and a press that had seen enough backroom dealing to distrust every banner waved in public. His journalist’s eye spots the continuity beneath the costume changes.
Subtextually, it’s also a critique of how “demagogue” functions as a socially acceptable way to say “the other team is illegitimate.” Marquis suggests we don’t deploy the term to defend institutions; we deploy it to defend our gang’s claim to the steering wheel. The joke works because it’s bleakly familiar: politics as a rotating cast of managers who disappoint, while citizens mistake their disappointment for discernment. Marquis doesn’t absolve the demagogue; he implicates the whole ecosystem that manufactures him.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|
More Quotes by Don
Add to List



