"A farmer travelling with his load Picked up a horseshoe on the road, And nailed if fast to his barn door, That luck might down upon him pour; That every blessing known in life Might crown his homestead and his wife, And never any kind of harm Descend upon his growing farm"
About this Quote
A horseshoe nailed to a barn door is folk technology: cheap, tactile, and reassuring in a world where weather, markets, and illness can wipe out a year’s work. Fields frames the farmer’s gesture with a steady rhyming pulse that mimics labor itself, as if superstition can be made as dependable as routine. The sing-song cadence isn’t just quaint; it’s doing persuasion, inviting the reader to feel how natural it is to translate anxiety into a small ritual.
The intent is less to mock the farmer than to stage a familiar bargain between effort and fate. Notice how quickly the poem shifts from “luck” to a full inventory of domestic hopes: “homestead,” “wife,” “growing farm.” The horseshoe isn’t about random fortune; it’s a talisman guarding a fragile ideal of stability. Fields stacks “every blessing” against “never any kind of harm,” exposing the fantasy at the heart of prosperity: not merely gain, but immunity.
Context matters: as a publisher and literary tastemaker in 19th-century New England, Fields would have known the era’s tension between Enlightenment rationality and persistent rural belief. The poem leans into that tension without resolving it. By presenting superstition as practical housekeeping, it quietly suggests that modern life doesn’t abolish magical thinking; it just relocates it to whatever symbols we can afford and control. The barn door becomes a threshold between the uncontrollable outside world and the curated story people tell themselves to keep going.
The intent is less to mock the farmer than to stage a familiar bargain between effort and fate. Notice how quickly the poem shifts from “luck” to a full inventory of domestic hopes: “homestead,” “wife,” “growing farm.” The horseshoe isn’t about random fortune; it’s a talisman guarding a fragile ideal of stability. Fields stacks “every blessing” against “never any kind of harm,” exposing the fantasy at the heart of prosperity: not merely gain, but immunity.
Context matters: as a publisher and literary tastemaker in 19th-century New England, Fields would have known the era’s tension between Enlightenment rationality and persistent rural belief. The poem leans into that tension without resolving it. By presenting superstition as practical housekeeping, it quietly suggests that modern life doesn’t abolish magical thinking; it just relocates it to whatever symbols we can afford and control. The barn door becomes a threshold between the uncontrollable outside world and the curated story people tell themselves to keep going.
Quote Details
| Topic | Family |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by James
Add to List










