"A first impulse was never a crime"
About this Quote
“A first impulse was never a crime” is Corneille doing what great dramatists do best: putting a legal-sounding line in the mouth of emotion, then daring the audience to believe it. The phrasing borrows the vocabulary of courts and confessionals, but it’s really a defense brief for the human heart. “Impulse” suggests speed and heat; “crime” drags in punishment, surveillance, the state. Between them sits a moral loophole: you can be tempted, even briefly delighted by the temptation, without being guilty.
That’s the subtext of so much 17th-century French tragedy, where honor is public property and private feeling is a threat. Corneille’s characters are forever caught between what they want and what their rank requires, with every glance or hesitation potentially incriminating. By exonerating the “first” impulse, he draws a crucial line between involuntary spark and deliberate act. Desire becomes a reflex, not a decision. The line doesn’t deny ethics; it reassigns where ethics starts: not at the flash of wanting, but at what you do once you’ve noticed you want.
It’s also a clever psychological move. Calling the impulse “first” implies there will be a second, a third: the moment where self-control either shows up as virtue or collapses into plot. Corneille grants his characters a sliver of mercy so the drama can focus on the real battlefield - choice under pressure, and the humiliating fact that the noblest people still have nervous systems.
That’s the subtext of so much 17th-century French tragedy, where honor is public property and private feeling is a threat. Corneille’s characters are forever caught between what they want and what their rank requires, with every glance or hesitation potentially incriminating. By exonerating the “first” impulse, he draws a crucial line between involuntary spark and deliberate act. Desire becomes a reflex, not a decision. The line doesn’t deny ethics; it reassigns where ethics starts: not at the flash of wanting, but at what you do once you’ve noticed you want.
It’s also a clever psychological move. Calling the impulse “first” implies there will be a second, a third: the moment where self-control either shows up as virtue or collapses into plot. Corneille grants his characters a sliver of mercy so the drama can focus on the real battlefield - choice under pressure, and the humiliating fact that the noblest people still have nervous systems.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Pierre
Add to List
