"A great man is made up of qualities that meet or make great occasions"
About this Quote
Greatness, Lowell suggests, isn’t a fixed halo you wear in peacetime; it’s a toolkit that only looks like destiny when history starts making demands. The line is engineered to demystify “great men” without fully dethroning them. He keeps the romantic shine of heroism, but shifts the mechanism: not divine favor, not pedigree, not pure ambition, but a set of qualities that either rise to meet pressure or actively manufacture the moment that will justify them.
The clever hinge is “meet or make.” Meet implies responsiveness: character revealed under stress, the old Protestant idea that trials are a proving ground. Make implies agency, even opportunism: the great figure doesn’t just answer the call; he drafts the script, reframes the stakes, turns private conviction into public necessity. That two-step protects Lowell from cynicism. He can admire leadership without pretending it’s accidental, and he can praise initiative without celebrating mere self-promotion.
Context matters. Lowell, a poet and public moralist in 19th-century America, lived through abolitionist conflict and the Civil War era’s hunger for exemplary figures. His culture was obsessed with “great men” as civic glue, but also anxious about how easily charisma curdles into myth. This sentence functions like a disciplined antidote to hero worship: it relocates greatness in transferable qualities (courage, judgment, endurance) while acknowledging the brutal truth that occasions are not neutral. They are made by conflict, and sometimes by the very people we later applaud for “rising” to them.
The clever hinge is “meet or make.” Meet implies responsiveness: character revealed under stress, the old Protestant idea that trials are a proving ground. Make implies agency, even opportunism: the great figure doesn’t just answer the call; he drafts the script, reframes the stakes, turns private conviction into public necessity. That two-step protects Lowell from cynicism. He can admire leadership without pretending it’s accidental, and he can praise initiative without celebrating mere self-promotion.
Context matters. Lowell, a poet and public moralist in 19th-century America, lived through abolitionist conflict and the Civil War era’s hunger for exemplary figures. His culture was obsessed with “great men” as civic glue, but also anxious about how easily charisma curdles into myth. This sentence functions like a disciplined antidote to hero worship: it relocates greatness in transferable qualities (courage, judgment, endurance) while acknowledging the brutal truth that occasions are not neutral. They are made by conflict, and sometimes by the very people we later applaud for “rising” to them.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by James
Add to List













