"A Jew without Jews, without Judaism, without Zionism, without Jewishness, without a temple or an army or even a pistol, a Jew clearly without a home, just the object itself, like a glass or an apple"
About this Quote
Roth strips identity down to its bare, unnerving remainder: a person reduced to a category once every living context has been peeled away. The piling up of negations ("without Jews, without Judaism, without Zionism") is a legal brief written by a cynic, each clause disqualifying another familiar anchor of belonging: religion, politics, culture, community. What’s left isn’t freedom; it’s exposure. By the time he lands on "without a temple or an army or even a pistol", Roth has moved from metaphysics to survival. The temple suggests tradition, the army sovereignty, the pistol the smallest private claim to safety. Each is denied. The phrase "clearly without a home" reads less like a description than a verdict.
Then comes the sting: "just the object itself, like a glass or an apple". Roth is playing with the modern fantasy that identity can be made neutral, that you can sand off history and arrive at a clean, universal human. He treats that fantasy as a kind of dehumanization: an object is legible, classifiable, consumable. A glass is transparent; an apple is ripe for taking. The similes carry the subtext of display and appetite - the "Jew" as something seen, handled, and judged, rather than a self with interiority.
Context matters because Roth’s work obsessively stages the fight between imposed Jewishness and chosen Jewishness, especially in postwar America, where assimilation promises safety while never quite delivering innocence. The quote’s intent is not to erase Jewish identity but to show how quickly a person becomes vulnerable when their identity is reduced to a label without the protections - social, cultural, political - that make any identity livable.
Then comes the sting: "just the object itself, like a glass or an apple". Roth is playing with the modern fantasy that identity can be made neutral, that you can sand off history and arrive at a clean, universal human. He treats that fantasy as a kind of dehumanization: an object is legible, classifiable, consumable. A glass is transparent; an apple is ripe for taking. The similes carry the subtext of display and appetite - the "Jew" as something seen, handled, and judged, rather than a self with interiority.
Context matters because Roth’s work obsessively stages the fight between imposed Jewishness and chosen Jewishness, especially in postwar America, where assimilation promises safety while never quite delivering innocence. The quote’s intent is not to erase Jewish identity but to show how quickly a person becomes vulnerable when their identity is reduced to a label without the protections - social, cultural, political - that make any identity livable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Deep |
|---|
More Quotes by Philip
Add to List
