"A lasting order cannot be established by bayonets"
About this Quote
Mises’s line lands like a calm rebuke to the perennial fantasy that society can be “fixed” through force if only the state grips the handle hard enough. “Bayonets” is chosen with surgical precision: not an abstract “violence,” but the intimate tool of occupation and crowd control, the kind of coercion that keeps bodies compliant while minds and incentives quietly revolt. The verb “established” does extra work, too. It nods to the technocratic dream of designing order the way you’d draft a budget - as if stability were a policy you could implement, rather than a social arrangement people consent to because it serves their interests.
The subtext is classic Mises: durable order comes from voluntary coordination (markets, contracts, norms), not the temporary stillness produced by fear. Bayonets can freeze a street corner; they can’t make prices communicate scarcity, can’t conjure trust between strangers, can’t generate legitimacy for rules people experience as extraction. Coercion can win the day and still lose the decade.
Context matters. Mises lived through the collapse of empires, revolutionary upheaval, and the rise of totalitarian regimes that treated politics as an engineering problem with a military solution. His warning isn’t pacifism; it’s a diagnosis of state power’s limits. Force can suppress symptoms while deepening the disease - creating black markets, sabotage, capital flight, and the resentments that eventually require even more force. The line works because it refuses drama. It’s not a moral wail; it’s a sober forecast: if your “order” needs bayonets to breathe, it’s already dying.
The subtext is classic Mises: durable order comes from voluntary coordination (markets, contracts, norms), not the temporary stillness produced by fear. Bayonets can freeze a street corner; they can’t make prices communicate scarcity, can’t conjure trust between strangers, can’t generate legitimacy for rules people experience as extraction. Coercion can win the day and still lose the decade.
Context matters. Mises lived through the collapse of empires, revolutionary upheaval, and the rise of totalitarian regimes that treated politics as an engineering problem with a military solution. His warning isn’t pacifism; it’s a diagnosis of state power’s limits. Force can suppress symptoms while deepening the disease - creating black markets, sabotage, capital flight, and the resentments that eventually require even more force. The line works because it refuses drama. It’s not a moral wail; it’s a sober forecast: if your “order” needs bayonets to breathe, it’s already dying.
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|
More Quotes by Ludwig
Add to List









