"A little reflection will show us that every belief, even the simplest and most fundamental, goes beyond experience when regarded as a guide to our actions"
About this Quote
Clifford is doing something sly here: he’s dressing a moral warning in the calm, respectable clothes of epistemology. As a mathematician who helped shape modern standards of rigor, he’s suspicious of the way people smuggle “common sense” into decisions as if it were evidence. His claim isn’t that experience is useless; it’s that the moment a belief starts steering your actions, it stops being a mere record of what happened and becomes a wager about what will happen next. Belief, in other words, is always a leap. The question is whether you admit it’s a leap and demand good reasons, or pretend you’re just following the facts.
The intent is disciplinary: to unsettle the comforting hierarchy in which “fundamental” beliefs get a free pass while only exotic doctrines are asked to show their work. Clifford’s subtext is ethical and social. In Victorian Britain, arguments about faith, scientific authority, and imperial “civilizing” missions weren’t abstract parlor games; they justified policy, power, and harm. If your beliefs exceed experience, then they can’t hide behind innocence. You are responsible for the extra you’ve added: the assumptions, the probabilities, the inherited narratives.
What makes the line work is its quiet reversal. “Even the simplest” is a trapdoor under the reader’s feet: the very beliefs you treat as natural are the ones most likely to operate uninspected. Clifford’s cool tone implies a bracing conclusion: rationality isn’t just a method; it’s a civic duty, because actions multiply private credulity into public consequences.
The intent is disciplinary: to unsettle the comforting hierarchy in which “fundamental” beliefs get a free pass while only exotic doctrines are asked to show their work. Clifford’s subtext is ethical and social. In Victorian Britain, arguments about faith, scientific authority, and imperial “civilizing” missions weren’t abstract parlor games; they justified policy, power, and harm. If your beliefs exceed experience, then they can’t hide behind innocence. You are responsible for the extra you’ve added: the assumptions, the probabilities, the inherited narratives.
What makes the line work is its quiet reversal. “Even the simplest” is a trapdoor under the reader’s feet: the very beliefs you treat as natural are the ones most likely to operate uninspected. Clifford’s cool tone implies a bracing conclusion: rationality isn’t just a method; it’s a civic duty, because actions multiply private credulity into public consequences.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List
