"A lot of it just has to do with luck, serendipity"
About this Quote
“A lot of it just has to do with luck, serendipity” is Emanuel Ax doing something quietly radical in a culture that loves origin myths: refusing the heroic narrative. Coming from a pianist whose career reads like a chain of big-league validations (major competitions, top orchestras, long-standing collaborations), the line lands less as false modesty than as a corrective. He’s not denying discipline; he’s demoting it from the starring role.
The intent is to widen the frame around success in the arts. Classical music, maybe more than any other field, fetishizes meritocracy: the right teacher, the right repertoire, the right age to debut, the right “sound.” Ax punctures that story with two words that imply different kinds of chance. “Luck” is blunt and unsentimental: being born with certain hands, ears, resources, passports, or health. “Serendipity” adds narrative texture: the last-minute substitution that becomes a breakthrough, the collaborator you meet at a festival, the audition panel that happens to be listening for what you naturally do.
Subtextually, it’s also an ethical position. By foregrounding randomness, Ax resists turning achievement into a moral verdict on those who didn’t make it. He’s acknowledging the invisible scaffolding behind every “genius”: timing, gatekeepers, patronage, and the fickle tastes of institutions. In an era when musicians are expected to brand themselves as unstoppable hustlers, his admission is a reminder that art careers aren’t just built; they’re also bestowed, occasionally, by accident. That honesty doesn’t weaken the achievement. It humanizes it.
The intent is to widen the frame around success in the arts. Classical music, maybe more than any other field, fetishizes meritocracy: the right teacher, the right repertoire, the right age to debut, the right “sound.” Ax punctures that story with two words that imply different kinds of chance. “Luck” is blunt and unsentimental: being born with certain hands, ears, resources, passports, or health. “Serendipity” adds narrative texture: the last-minute substitution that becomes a breakthrough, the collaborator you meet at a festival, the audition panel that happens to be listening for what you naturally do.
Subtextually, it’s also an ethical position. By foregrounding randomness, Ax resists turning achievement into a moral verdict on those who didn’t make it. He’s acknowledging the invisible scaffolding behind every “genius”: timing, gatekeepers, patronage, and the fickle tastes of institutions. In an era when musicians are expected to brand themselves as unstoppable hustlers, his admission is a reminder that art careers aren’t just built; they’re also bestowed, occasionally, by accident. That honesty doesn’t weaken the achievement. It humanizes it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Emanuel
Add to List









