"A man has no religion who has not slowly and painfully gathered one together, adding to it, shaping it; and one's religion is never complete and final, it seems, but must always be undergoing modification"
About this Quote
Lawrence isn’t praising spiritual certainty; he’s indicting it. By insisting that religion must be “slowly and painfully gathered,” he flips faith from inheritance to labor, from community badge to private construction site. The sting is in the opening: “A man has no religion…” Unless it’s earned through friction, it doesn’t count. That’s not a gentle nudge toward sincerity so much as a refusal to let borrowed creeds pass as inner life.
The sentence builds its argument the way Lawrence thinks belief should build: accretive, provisional, stubbornly unfinished. “Adding to it, shaping it” frames religion less as revelation than as craft. Subtext: the self is not a vessel to be filled but a force that must wrestle meaning into form. The pain matters because it’s the proof of contact with reality - with desire, doubt, mortality, sex, and the body, Lawrence’s recurring battlegrounds against pious abstraction.
Context sharpens the edge. Writing in early 20th-century England, with institutional Christianity still culturally dominant but increasingly threadbare under modernity’s pressures, Lawrence aims at both sides: the church’s dead formalism and modern skepticism’s easy superiority. He rejects the idea that you can opt out of religion without replacing it with something equally demanding. Even the phrase “never complete and final” reads like a warning against ideological embalming: when belief stops “undergoing modification,” it hardens into performance, then into control.
It works because it treats faith as a living organism, not a museum artifact - and because it dares the reader to admit how much of their “religion,” religious or not, is just unexamined hand-me-downs.
The sentence builds its argument the way Lawrence thinks belief should build: accretive, provisional, stubbornly unfinished. “Adding to it, shaping it” frames religion less as revelation than as craft. Subtext: the self is not a vessel to be filled but a force that must wrestle meaning into form. The pain matters because it’s the proof of contact with reality - with desire, doubt, mortality, sex, and the body, Lawrence’s recurring battlegrounds against pious abstraction.
Context sharpens the edge. Writing in early 20th-century England, with institutional Christianity still culturally dominant but increasingly threadbare under modernity’s pressures, Lawrence aims at both sides: the church’s dead formalism and modern skepticism’s easy superiority. He rejects the idea that you can opt out of religion without replacing it with something equally demanding. Even the phrase “never complete and final” reads like a warning against ideological embalming: when belief stops “undergoing modification,” it hardens into performance, then into control.
It works because it treats faith as a living organism, not a museum artifact - and because it dares the reader to admit how much of their “religion,” religious or not, is just unexamined hand-me-downs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by David
Add to List
