"A man may well be condemned, not for doing something, but for doing nothing"
About this Quote
Barclay turns morality on its head by treating inaction as an action with consequences. The line carries the quiet sting of Christian ethics: sin is not just the flashy, prosecutable wrongdoing; it is also the refusal to show up when love, justice, or mercy require effort. The phrasing is legalistic on purpose. "Condemned" evokes judgment, a court, a verdict, and by extension the divine courtroom that sits behind much of Barclay's theology. He isn’t offering a gentle reminder to be nicer; he’s indicting the comfortable habit of watching harm unfold and calling it neutrality.
The subtext is aimed at the respectable, not the scandalous. Doing nothing is the sin of the decent person who keeps their hands clean and their conscience intact by staying uninvolved. That’s why the construction is so stark: "not for doing something" (the obvious crime), "but for doing nothing" (the crime that hides in plain sight). Barclay is pressing on a tension at the core of modern moral life: systems of suffering rarely need many villains; they need crowds of bystanders.
Context matters. Barclay wrote and preached in a 20th century marked by war, mass displacement, and industrial-scale atrocity, alongside a growing welfare state that asked ordinary citizens to think in collective terms. In that world, ethical failure often looked like passivity: the neighbor ignored, the refugee turned away, the prejudice tolerated because it was inconvenient to challenge. Barclay’s intent is pastoral but unsparing: salvation is not merely avoiding evil; it’s practicing costly attention.
The subtext is aimed at the respectable, not the scandalous. Doing nothing is the sin of the decent person who keeps their hands clean and their conscience intact by staying uninvolved. That’s why the construction is so stark: "not for doing something" (the obvious crime), "but for doing nothing" (the crime that hides in plain sight). Barclay is pressing on a tension at the core of modern moral life: systems of suffering rarely need many villains; they need crowds of bystanders.
Context matters. Barclay wrote and preached in a 20th century marked by war, mass displacement, and industrial-scale atrocity, alongside a growing welfare state that asked ordinary citizens to think in collective terms. In that world, ethical failure often looked like passivity: the neighbor ignored, the refugee turned away, the prejudice tolerated because it was inconvenient to challenge. Barclay’s intent is pastoral but unsparing: salvation is not merely avoiding evil; it’s practicing costly attention.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by William
Add to List
