"A man of genius makes no mistakes; his errors are volitional and are the portals of discovery"
About this Quote
Genius, Joyce suggests, isn’t a cleaner version of talent; it’s a different relationship to failure. The line has the swagger of an artist refusing the courtroom terms of “mistake” and “error.” A “man of genius” doesn’t stumble into wrongness by accident because his work isn’t judged by the same rubric as ordinary competence. His “errors are volitional”: chosen, risked, authored. That one word yanks failure out of shame and back into agency, reframing the slip as an experiment, even a provocation.
Joyce is also smuggling in a defense of his own method. In the early 20th century, when literature was being reorganized by modernism’s fractures and formal rebellion, “mistakes” were often what reviewers called anything that didn’t behave. Joyce’s style - the syntactic pileups, the obsessive patterning, the deliberate overload - could read like malfunction to a reader expecting Victorian clarity. This aphorism flips the accusation: if you think it’s broken, you’re holding the wrong measuring tool.
The second clause is the real sales pitch. Errors aren’t merely excusable; they’re “portals,” an almost mythic image that elevates craft into exploration. Joyce isn’t romanticizing incompetence. He’s describing a creative ethic where the artist advances by pushing language until it warps, where discovery is less a stroke of inspiration than the byproduct of intentional misbehavior. Subtext: the future of art belongs to those willing to look wrong on the way to being new.
Joyce is also smuggling in a defense of his own method. In the early 20th century, when literature was being reorganized by modernism’s fractures and formal rebellion, “mistakes” were often what reviewers called anything that didn’t behave. Joyce’s style - the syntactic pileups, the obsessive patterning, the deliberate overload - could read like malfunction to a reader expecting Victorian clarity. This aphorism flips the accusation: if you think it’s broken, you’re holding the wrong measuring tool.
The second clause is the real sales pitch. Errors aren’t merely excusable; they’re “portals,” an almost mythic image that elevates craft into exploration. Joyce isn’t romanticizing incompetence. He’s describing a creative ethic where the artist advances by pushing language until it warps, where discovery is less a stroke of inspiration than the byproduct of intentional misbehavior. Subtext: the future of art belongs to those willing to look wrong on the way to being new.
Quote Details
| Topic | Learning from Mistakes |
|---|
More Quotes by James
Add to List
