"A military life has ever comported with my inclination"
About this Quote
A military life has ever comported with my inclination: the sentence is stiff with 19th-century self-control, and that stiffness is the point. Stoneman isn’t offering a romantic call to arms; he’s filing a claim. “Comported” does bureaucratic work, translating something as volatile as appetite into something that sounds orderly, reasonable, almost pre-approved. “Ever” stretches the impulse backward into destiny. It’s a quiet bid for legitimacy in an era when officers were expected to project steadiness, not longing.
The intent is career-minded as much as it is confessional. In the mid-century American officer class, especially for West Point-trained men, military service wasn’t just a job; it was a social identity built on discipline, hierarchy, and a certain patrician distance from civilian chaos. Saying the life “comported” with him frames war and command as an extension of character rather than an opportunistic choice. It’s the kind of line that reads well in official correspondence, memoir, or a recommendation: ambition disguised as temperament.
The subtext is also defensive. To claim inclination is to dodge harsher motives: hunger for rank, taste for coercion, the lure of adventure. Stoneman’s Civil War record and later prominence would have made scrutiny inevitable; this phrasing preemptively casts his decisions as consistent, not self-serving. It’s self-fashioning in a single clause: not “I wanted it,” but “I was suited for it,” which is a more socially acceptable way of saying the same thing while sounding like fate.
The intent is career-minded as much as it is confessional. In the mid-century American officer class, especially for West Point-trained men, military service wasn’t just a job; it was a social identity built on discipline, hierarchy, and a certain patrician distance from civilian chaos. Saying the life “comported” with him frames war and command as an extension of character rather than an opportunistic choice. It’s the kind of line that reads well in official correspondence, memoir, or a recommendation: ambition disguised as temperament.
The subtext is also defensive. To claim inclination is to dodge harsher motives: hunger for rank, taste for coercion, the lure of adventure. Stoneman’s Civil War record and later prominence would have made scrutiny inevitable; this phrasing preemptively casts his decisions as consistent, not self-serving. It’s self-fashioning in a single clause: not “I wanted it,” but “I was suited for it,” which is a more socially acceptable way of saying the same thing while sounding like fate.
Quote Details
| Topic | Military & Soldier |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by George
Add to List



