"A mortal lives not through that breath that flows in and that flows out. The source of his life is another and this causes the breath to flow"
About this Quote
Paracelsus takes a basic fact of biology - breathing - and strips it of its authority. You think you are alive because you inhale and exhale; he insists that breath is only the visible ripple, not the spring. The line works because it flips causality: respiration isn’t the engine of life but its exhaust. That reversal is a quiet rebuke to the era’s emerging habit of treating the body like a set of mechanical parts you can fully explain by watching what moves.
The subtext is anti-reductionist, and it’s also a flex. Paracelsus built his reputation by attacking medical orthodoxy, mocking bookish Galenism, and insisting that observation and experiment matter. Yet here he’s not a pure materialist; he’s staking out a middle ground where chemistry, cosmology, and something like vital force coexist. “The source of his life is another” is deliberately vague: it can mean God, the soul, the archeus (his proposed inner alchemist), or the larger macrocosm that Renaissance thinkers believed the body mirrored. Ambiguity is doing strategic work, letting him sound empirical while keeping metaphysical depth intact.
Context matters: in the 16th century, breath carried theological and symbolic weight (spiritus, pneuma). Paracelsus borrows that tradition to argue that life can’t be captured by counting breaths or mapping organs. His intent isn’t to deny physiology; it’s to remind physicians that symptoms are downstream. Treat the breath alone and you’re treating a consequence, not a cause - a warning that still lands in any culture tempted to mistake metrics for meaning.
The subtext is anti-reductionist, and it’s also a flex. Paracelsus built his reputation by attacking medical orthodoxy, mocking bookish Galenism, and insisting that observation and experiment matter. Yet here he’s not a pure materialist; he’s staking out a middle ground where chemistry, cosmology, and something like vital force coexist. “The source of his life is another” is deliberately vague: it can mean God, the soul, the archeus (his proposed inner alchemist), or the larger macrocosm that Renaissance thinkers believed the body mirrored. Ambiguity is doing strategic work, letting him sound empirical while keeping metaphysical depth intact.
Context matters: in the 16th century, breath carried theological and symbolic weight (spiritus, pneuma). Paracelsus borrows that tradition to argue that life can’t be captured by counting breaths or mapping organs. His intent isn’t to deny physiology; it’s to remind physicians that symptoms are downstream. Treat the breath alone and you’re treating a consequence, not a cause - a warning that still lands in any culture tempted to mistake metrics for meaning.
Quote Details
| Topic | Meaning of Life |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Philipus
Add to List





