"A murderer is regarded by the conventional world as something almost monstrous, but a murderer to himself is only an ordinary man. It is only if the murderer is a good man that he can be regarded as monstrous"
About this Quote
Greene’s nastiest trick here is the reversal: the “conventional world” needs the murderer to be a monster because that story keeps everyone else clean. Monstrousness becomes less a fact than a social convenience, a way to quarantine evil in a single body and keep it from bleeding into the ordinary. But Greene’s camera swings inward. To the murderer, the act has already been normalized by motive, fear, habit, ideology, adrenaline - the private narrative that makes any choice feel, at the moment of doing, like the only choice.
Then comes the kicker: “only if the murderer is a good man.” Greene isn’t excusing murder; he’s accusing our moral imagination. A “good” murderer is monstrous precisely because he breaks the comforting equation between violence and obvious villainy. If a killer is cruel, greedy, or cartoonishly depraved, society can file him under the expected category and move on. If he’s recognizably decent - tender to his child, capable of remorse, sincerely trying to live by a code - the act becomes intolerable because it implicates the rest of us. It suggests that the boundary between civility and atrocity isn’t a species difference, it’s a circumstance.
That’s Greene’s Catholic-tinged preoccupation: sin as something committed by souls who can still feel grace. The line carries the worldliness of his thrillers and the dread of his moral fiction. He’s reminding you that “monsters” are often just people we can’t bear to recognize as neighbors.
Then comes the kicker: “only if the murderer is a good man.” Greene isn’t excusing murder; he’s accusing our moral imagination. A “good” murderer is monstrous precisely because he breaks the comforting equation between violence and obvious villainy. If a killer is cruel, greedy, or cartoonishly depraved, society can file him under the expected category and move on. If he’s recognizably decent - tender to his child, capable of remorse, sincerely trying to live by a code - the act becomes intolerable because it implicates the rest of us. It suggests that the boundary between civility and atrocity isn’t a species difference, it’s a circumstance.
That’s Greene’s Catholic-tinged preoccupation: sin as something committed by souls who can still feel grace. The line carries the worldliness of his thrillers and the dread of his moral fiction. He’s reminding you that “monsters” are often just people we can’t bear to recognize as neighbors.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Graham
Add to List









