"A new word is like a fresh seed sown on the ground of the discussion"
About this Quote
Language, for Wittgenstein, is never just a neutral delivery system for thoughts you already have. It is the machinery that makes certain thoughts possible at all. That is why the metaphor lands: a “new word” isn’t a label pasted onto a preexisting object; it’s a seed. Put it into the soil of conversation and you don’t merely add vocabulary, you alter what can grow there.
The intent is quietly polemical. Wittgenstein spent his career attacking the idea that philosophical problems are deep mysteries waiting for technical solutions. Many of them, he argues, are the result of language gone slightly feral: words used outside their ordinary “forms of life,” terms that hypnotize us into thinking we’re pointing at something definite. In that light, “fresh seed” is both promise and warning. Introducing a term can open a field of new distinctions, new questions, new practices. It can also generate a whole crop of pseudo-problems if the word’s use isn’t anchored in how people actually live and speak.
The subtext is social. “Discussion” isn’t a private mental arena; it’s the communal space where meaning is negotiated through use. A coined word can function like a tool: it reorganizes attention, invites alliances, polices boundaries, and creates status (who gets to name, who must adopt). Wittgenstein’s larger context - post-Truth, post-empire Europe, and the analytic obsession with precision - makes the line feel like a corrective: if you want clearer thinking, watch what you plant.
The intent is quietly polemical. Wittgenstein spent his career attacking the idea that philosophical problems are deep mysteries waiting for technical solutions. Many of them, he argues, are the result of language gone slightly feral: words used outside their ordinary “forms of life,” terms that hypnotize us into thinking we’re pointing at something definite. In that light, “fresh seed” is both promise and warning. Introducing a term can open a field of new distinctions, new questions, new practices. It can also generate a whole crop of pseudo-problems if the word’s use isn’t anchored in how people actually live and speak.
The subtext is social. “Discussion” isn’t a private mental arena; it’s the communal space where meaning is negotiated through use. A coined word can function like a tool: it reorganizes attention, invites alliances, polices boundaries, and creates status (who gets to name, who must adopt). Wittgenstein’s larger context - post-Truth, post-empire Europe, and the analytic obsession with precision - makes the line feel like a corrective: if you want clearer thinking, watch what you plant.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Ludwig
Add to List
