Art & Creativity Quote by Chaim Potok

"A non-fiction writer pretty much has the shape of the figure in front of him or her and goes about refining it. A work of non-fiction is not as difficult to write as a work of fiction, but it's not as satisfying in the end"

Chaim Potok, Author

About this Quote

Potok’s provocation lands because it flatters and needles at the same time: non-fiction gets a “figure in front of” you, fiction has to conjure the figure, pose it, and then convince the reader it was always there. The metaphor is quietly visual and almost sculptural. The non-fiction writer “refines” an existing shape; the novelist manufactures the clay, the tools, and the illusion of inevitability.

The intent isn’t to dunk on non-fiction so much as to defend the particular loneliness of invention. Potok spent his career writing novels steeped in dense cultural reality - Orthodox Judaism, intellectual inheritance, assimilation, rupture. He understood research, history, and lived experience. Yet he’s insisting that even when fiction borrows heavily from life, the labor is different: facts can anchor you, but they also limit you. In non-fiction, the constraint is the selling point: you’re accountable to what happened. In fiction, the constraint is internal: you’re accountable to what would happen given the world you’ve built.

The subtext is about artistic satisfaction, not difficulty as a macho contest. Non-fiction can be hard in the way craftsmanship is hard; fiction is hard in the way creation is hard, because the standards are mercilessly private. A nonfiction book can “work” by being accurate and well-argued. A novel has to earn something less measurable: the sense that you’ve touched a human truth without being able to cite your sources.

Potok’s line also reads as a warning to writers: don’t mistake proximity to reality for depth. Refinement is not revelation. Fiction, at its best, risks more - and pays off with a deeper kind of closure.

Quote Details

Topic	Writing
Source	Help us find the source
Cite	Cite this Quote

More Quotes by Chaim Add to List

About the Author

Chaim Potok (February 17, 1929 - July 23, 2002) was a Author from USA.

27 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"I am conscious of trying to stretch the boundaries of non-fiction writing. It's always surprised me how little attention many non-fiction writers pay to the formal aspects of their work"

Alain de Botton, Writer

"His theory was that non-fiction could be as artful as fiction"

Gerald Clarke, Politician

"Writing fiction is for me a fraught business, an occasion of daily dread for at least the first half of the novel, and sometimes all the way through. The work process is totally different from writing nonfiction. You have to sit down every day and make it up"

Joan Didion, Author

"What I like about non-fiction is that it covers such a huge territory. The best non-fiction is also creative"

Tracy Kidder, Author

"Basically, fiction is people. You can't write fiction about ideas"

Theodore Sturgeon, Writer

"The pleasure of writing fiction is that you are always spotting some new approach, an alternative way of telling a story and manipulating characters; the novel is such a wonderfully flexible form"

Penelope Lively, Author

"Some major writers have a huge impact, like Ayn Rand, who to my mind is a lousy fiction writer because her writing has no compassion and virtually no humor. She has a philosophical and economical message that she is passing off as fiction, but it really isn't fiction at all"

Theodore Sturgeon, Writer

"The reason that fiction is more interesting than any other form of literature, to those who really like to study people, is that in fiction the author can really tell the truth without humiliating himself"

Jim Rohn, Businessman

Jim Rohn

"Whereas fiction is a continual discovery of what one wants to say, what one feels, what one means, and is, in that sense, a performance art, biography requires different skills - research and organization"

Edmund White, Novelist

"I want prose fiction to be recognized as that, and I'm not interested in writing as it becomes more personal"

John C. Hawkes, Novelist

"However far fiction writers stray from their own lives and experiences - and I stray pretty far from mine - I think, ultimately, that we may be writing what we need to write in some way, albeit unconsciously"

Wally Lamb, Author

"I think that there are fiction writers for whom that works well. I could never do it. I feel as if, by the time I see that it's a poem, it's almost written in my head somewhere"

Sharon Olds, Poet

"A masterpiece of fiction is an original world and as such is not likely to fit the world of the reader"

Vladimir Nabokov, Novelist

Vladimir Nabokov

"I came to the conclusion that I am not a fiction writer"

Tim LaHaye, Clergyman

"Good fiction must be entertaining, but what makes fiction special - and True - is that the realness of a novel allows it to carry a larger message"

Jerry B. Jenkins, Novelist

Jerry B. Jenkins

"I don't read fiction at all"

Brent Spiner, Actor

"Good fiction is made of that which is real, and reality is difficult to come by"

Ralph Ellison, Author

"I don't mean that literary fiction is better than genre fiction, On the contrary; novels can perform two functions and most perform only one"

Mark Haddon, Novelist

"If you write a story based on a real person, you're trapped by the details of the real person and his life. It gets in the way of writing your own story"

Caroline B. Cooney, Writer

Caroline B. Cooney

"Every writer knows he is spurious; every fiction writer would rather be credible than authentic"

John Le Carre, Author

John Le Carre