"A novel must be exceptionally good to live as long as the average cat"
About this Quote
Literary immortality, Lord Chesterfield suggests, has the life expectancy of a household pet: warm, admired, and ultimately disposable unless it’s truly extraordinary. The line lands because it yokes two mismatched scales - the grand pretensions of “a novel” and the stubborn ordinariness of “the average cat.” In one stroke, he shrinks the writer’s dream of permanence down to something domestic and faintly comic. The joke isn’t just that most books die; it’s that they die quickly, and the benchmark for “long” is embarrassingly modest.
Chesterfield writes from a statesman’s vantage point in an era when print culture is expanding, literacy is climbing, and the marketplace is beginning to crowd with new titles, new tastes, new forms of distraction. His world is not yet the industrialized churn of modern publishing, but it’s already noisy enough to make durability feel rare. The cat functions as a quiet statistic: familiar, measurable, unromantic. It’s a rebuke to authors who mistake publication for posterity.
Subtextually, there’s also an aristocratic chill. Chesterfield was a connoisseur of polish and reputation; he understood how quickly fashion turns and how brutally time edits. The line flatters discernment while warning against vanity: if you want your book to outlive a pet, it can’t merely be “good,” or even “popular.” It has to be “exceptionally good” - a standard that makes oblivion the default and survival an almost accidental miracle.
Chesterfield writes from a statesman’s vantage point in an era when print culture is expanding, literacy is climbing, and the marketplace is beginning to crowd with new titles, new tastes, new forms of distraction. His world is not yet the industrialized churn of modern publishing, but it’s already noisy enough to make durability feel rare. The cat functions as a quiet statistic: familiar, measurable, unromantic. It’s a rebuke to authors who mistake publication for posterity.
Subtextually, there’s also an aristocratic chill. Chesterfield was a connoisseur of polish and reputation; he understood how quickly fashion turns and how brutally time edits. The line flatters discernment while warning against vanity: if you want your book to outlive a pet, it can’t merely be “good,” or even “popular.” It has to be “exceptionally good” - a standard that makes oblivion the default and survival an almost accidental miracle.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Lord
Add to List





