"A Parliament is nothing less than a big meeting of more or less idle people"
About this Quote
Bagehot’s jab works because it flatters the reader’s suspicion while smuggling in a constitutional lesson. Calling Parliament “a big meeting” punctures the sanctimony of statecraft: no mystic “will of the people,” just humans in a room, talking, posturing, waiting. The sting is in “more or less idle.” He’s not merely accusing MPs of laziness; he’s mocking the fact that much of politics is structured downtime - long debates, procedural circling, the deliberate slow grind that looks like waste if you expect government to behave like a factory.
The subtext is Bagehot’s trademark realism about liberal institutions. In mid-Victorian Britain, Parliament was expanding its representative reach while the public was learning to watch politics like a spectator sport. Bagehot, who anatomized the English constitution with surgeon-like coolness, understood that legitimacy depends on performance as much as on outcomes. A chamber full of “idle people” is also a chamber available for persuasion, coalition-building, and the public signaling that keeps the system from snapping into pure executive command.
There’s an irony, too: idleness can be a feature, not a bug. Legislatures are designed to be inefficient compared to a monarch, a prime minister, or a boardroom. The waiting, the grandstanding, the committee churn - all of it creates friction, and friction is what turns raw power into something that has to explain itself. Bagehot needles Parliament to remind you that democracy often looks unserious precisely because it refuses to be swift.
The subtext is Bagehot’s trademark realism about liberal institutions. In mid-Victorian Britain, Parliament was expanding its representative reach while the public was learning to watch politics like a spectator sport. Bagehot, who anatomized the English constitution with surgeon-like coolness, understood that legitimacy depends on performance as much as on outcomes. A chamber full of “idle people” is also a chamber available for persuasion, coalition-building, and the public signaling that keeps the system from snapping into pure executive command.
There’s an irony, too: idleness can be a feature, not a bug. Legislatures are designed to be inefficient compared to a monarch, a prime minister, or a boardroom. The waiting, the grandstanding, the committee churn - all of it creates friction, and friction is what turns raw power into something that has to explain itself. Bagehot needles Parliament to remind you that democracy often looks unserious precisely because it refuses to be swift.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List




