"A prisoner in the Inquisition is never allowed to see the face of his accuser, or of the witnesses against him, but every method is taken by threats and tortures, to oblige him to accuse himself, and by that means corroborate their evidence"
About this Quote
Foxe frames injustice as a machine that runs best in the dark: keep the accuser invisible, keep the evidence unchallengeable, then manufacture “truth” from the only raw material left - the prisoner’s own broken voice. The sentence is engineered to feel procedural (“never allowed,” “every method is taken”), because Foxe’s point isn’t that cruelty happens; it’s that cruelty gets laundered into process. By emphasizing the missing face - not just the missing name - he spotlights how anonymity isn’t a neutral safeguard but a weapon that strips the accused of the basic human encounter where accountability begins.
The subtext is Protestant polemic with a lawyer’s cadence. Writing in the shadow of Marian persecutions and a Europe still arguing over who gets to define heresy, Foxe wants the reader to see Catholic tribunals not as misguided but as structurally incapable of justice. His tight pairing of “threats and tortures” with “oblige him to accuse himself” lands a cynical insight: confession here isn’t moral reckoning; it’s administrative convenience. The system doesn’t discover guilt - it produces it, then calls the product “corroboration.”
What makes the line endure is its modern diagnosis of coerced self-incrimination. Foxe is warning that once a court prizes confession over contest, secrecy over scrutiny, it stops being a venue for truth and becomes an instrument for validating power. The brutality is obvious; the more disturbing accusation is bureaucratic: the Inquisition’s real innovation is turning suffering into evidence.
The subtext is Protestant polemic with a lawyer’s cadence. Writing in the shadow of Marian persecutions and a Europe still arguing over who gets to define heresy, Foxe wants the reader to see Catholic tribunals not as misguided but as structurally incapable of justice. His tight pairing of “threats and tortures” with “oblige him to accuse himself” lands a cynical insight: confession here isn’t moral reckoning; it’s administrative convenience. The system doesn’t discover guilt - it produces it, then calls the product “corroboration.”
What makes the line endure is its modern diagnosis of coerced self-incrimination. Foxe is warning that once a court prizes confession over contest, secrecy over scrutiny, it stops being a venue for truth and becomes an instrument for validating power. The brutality is obvious; the more disturbing accusation is bureaucratic: the Inquisition’s real innovation is turning suffering into evidence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List
