"A society deadened by a smothering network of laws while finding release in moral chaos is not likely to be either happy or stable"
About this Quote
Bork’s line is built like a vise: on one side, “a smothering network of laws,” on the other, “moral chaos.” The friction between those phrases is the point. He’s arguing that a culture can overregulate the visible, procedural parts of life while simultaneously losing the shared restraints that make freedom workable. It’s not just a complaint about “too many rules”; it’s a diagnosis of a society that replaces lived norms with paperwork, then acts shocked when the paperwork can’t produce meaning, trust, or self-control.
The subtext is a familiar conservative legal critique: when communities stop enforcing moral expectations informally (through family, religion, civic pressure), the state expands to fill the gap. Law becomes a substitute for virtue, and because law is blunt, it multiplies. People then experience that multiplication as suffocation and look for “release” in transgression, spectacle, or nihilism. The phrase “finding release” is doing quiet psychological work: chaos isn’t framed as an accident but as an addictive outlet, a rebound effect from constraint.
Context matters because Bork wasn’t a detached moralist; he was a combative public servant and jurist whose career collided with America’s late-20th-century culture wars. He saw courts and elites as licensing permissiveness while also building sprawling regulatory and rights-based systems. The warning about happiness and stability is strategic: it yokes private satisfaction to political order, suggesting that permissive culture and legal overreach aren’t opposing problems but two halves of one spiral.
The subtext is a familiar conservative legal critique: when communities stop enforcing moral expectations informally (through family, religion, civic pressure), the state expands to fill the gap. Law becomes a substitute for virtue, and because law is blunt, it multiplies. People then experience that multiplication as suffocation and look for “release” in transgression, spectacle, or nihilism. The phrase “finding release” is doing quiet psychological work: chaos isn’t framed as an accident but as an addictive outlet, a rebound effect from constraint.
Context matters because Bork wasn’t a detached moralist; he was a combative public servant and jurist whose career collided with America’s late-20th-century culture wars. He saw courts and elites as licensing permissiveness while also building sprawling regulatory and rights-based systems. The warning about happiness and stability is strategic: it yokes private satisfaction to political order, suggesting that permissive culture and legal overreach aren’t opposing problems but two halves of one spiral.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List








