"A thought is often original, though you have uttered it a hundred times"
About this Quote
Originality, Holmes suggests, isn’t a birth certificate you receive once and keep in a safe; it’s a flicker that can relight in the same mind, using the same words, on the hundredth strike of the match. In an era when America was busy defining itself culturally - trying to sound less like a British echo and more like its own literature - Holmes quietly shifts the debate. He’s less interested in owning ideas than in the moment an idea becomes newly alive.
The line works because it treats repetition not as failure but as proof of pressure. You “utter” the thought again and again, and yet it can return with the clean shock of discovery. That’s not mystical; it’s psychological. The self changes between utterances. Experience accumulates, grief and ambition rearrange the furniture, and suddenly an old sentence lands differently. The “often” does important work here: Holmes isn’t romanticizing perpetual novelty, he’s describing a recurring phenomenon anyone who writes, teaches, argues, prays, or loves recognizes.
Subtext: Holmes is puncturing the anxious, status-driven idea that originality is primarily about being first. A poet-physician with a public intellectual’s skepticism, he’s implying that what matters is not the timestamp but the charge - whether a thought arrives with real contact, not just recital. In a culture that rewards hot takes and proprietary brilliance, he’s offering a steadier metric: authenticity as renewed perception, not constant invention.
The line works because it treats repetition not as failure but as proof of pressure. You “utter” the thought again and again, and yet it can return with the clean shock of discovery. That’s not mystical; it’s psychological. The self changes between utterances. Experience accumulates, grief and ambition rearrange the furniture, and suddenly an old sentence lands differently. The “often” does important work here: Holmes isn’t romanticizing perpetual novelty, he’s describing a recurring phenomenon anyone who writes, teaches, argues, prays, or loves recognizes.
Subtext: Holmes is puncturing the anxious, status-driven idea that originality is primarily about being first. A poet-physician with a public intellectual’s skepticism, he’s implying that what matters is not the timestamp but the charge - whether a thought arrives with real contact, not just recital. In a culture that rewards hot takes and proprietary brilliance, he’s offering a steadier metric: authenticity as renewed perception, not constant invention.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Oliver
Add to List








