"Aaron Copland was a man that had a very specific point of view about what music should be which was that, he felt that new music should have the composer should show a personality in his music"
About this Quote
Copland shows up here less as a colleague than as a yardstick: a “very specific point of view” that quietly dares every other American composer to locate their own. Elliott Carter’s sentence is famously Carter-ish in its stop-start syntax, but the message is clean. Copland, he says, believed new music should “show a personality.” Not originality as a technical trick, not modernism as a badge, but audibility of self.
The subtext is a little sharper. Carter is describing an aesthetic ideology that helped mid-century American music market itself as distinct from Europe: clear profiles, recognizable voices, a sense that a piece announces who’s speaking. Copland’s own brand of open sonorities and prairie-spacious optimism made “personality” sound like democratic directness. Carter, whose music often stages conflicts between independent instrumental “characters,” hears that imperative and reframes it. Personality, for him, isn’t just melodic charm or accessible style; it’s structural identity, the way a mind thinks in time.
There’s also a gendered tell in “his music,” a reminder of how default-male the composer archetype remained in Carter’s era, even as “personality” was being treated as the moral core of new music. The line lands as both praise and pressure: Copland didn’t merely write pieces; he modeled an expectation that a composer’s inner life must be legible in sound. Carter’s nod acknowledges the power of that expectation while hinting at its limits. If personality becomes the rule, it can harden into a new orthodoxy, turning selfhood into yet another style to satisfy.
The subtext is a little sharper. Carter is describing an aesthetic ideology that helped mid-century American music market itself as distinct from Europe: clear profiles, recognizable voices, a sense that a piece announces who’s speaking. Copland’s own brand of open sonorities and prairie-spacious optimism made “personality” sound like democratic directness. Carter, whose music often stages conflicts between independent instrumental “characters,” hears that imperative and reframes it. Personality, for him, isn’t just melodic charm or accessible style; it’s structural identity, the way a mind thinks in time.
There’s also a gendered tell in “his music,” a reminder of how default-male the composer archetype remained in Carter’s era, even as “personality” was being treated as the moral core of new music. The line lands as both praise and pressure: Copland didn’t merely write pieces; he modeled an expectation that a composer’s inner life must be legible in sound. Carter’s nod acknowledges the power of that expectation while hinting at its limits. If personality becomes the rule, it can harden into a new orthodoxy, turning selfhood into yet another style to satisfy.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Elliott
Add to List
