"Ability is sexless"
About this Quote
“Ability is sexless” lands like a tidy aphorism, but it’s doing heavy, slightly risky work for a 19th-century clergyman. Newman compresses a social argument into four words: competence doesn’t come stamped “male” or “female,” so any system that allocates education, authority, or vocation on that basis is running on superstition, not reason. The phrase’s power is its blunt grammatical certainty. No sermonizing, no sentimental pleading, just an almost mathematical claim that tries to make prejudice sound irrational.
The subtext, though, is more tactical than radical. Newman isn’t necessarily flattening all differences between men and women; he’s carving out a protected category - “ability” - and declaring it outside the jurisdiction of gender. That maneuver matters in a Victorian context where “separate spheres” ideology was treated as moral common sense, and where women’s intellectual ambition was often framed as unnatural or even spiritually suspect. By making ability “sexless,” Newman gives respectability to the idea that women can be intellectually serious without becoming socially transgressive.
It’s also a cleric’s way of relocating the debate from desire to duty. If talent is a God-given endowment, then squandering it because of sex looks less like tradition and more like a failure of stewardship. The line borrows the authority of moral language while sounding like plain common sense - an argument designed to travel.
The subtext, though, is more tactical than radical. Newman isn’t necessarily flattening all differences between men and women; he’s carving out a protected category - “ability” - and declaring it outside the jurisdiction of gender. That maneuver matters in a Victorian context where “separate spheres” ideology was treated as moral common sense, and where women’s intellectual ambition was often framed as unnatural or even spiritually suspect. By making ability “sexless,” Newman gives respectability to the idea that women can be intellectually serious without becoming socially transgressive.
It’s also a cleric’s way of relocating the debate from desire to duty. If talent is a God-given endowment, then squandering it because of sex looks less like tradition and more like a failure of stewardship. The line borrows the authority of moral language while sounding like plain common sense - an argument designed to travel.
Quote Details
| Topic | Equality |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List







