"Abortion on demand has, in my judgment, contributed significantly to an environment in our country in which life has become very cheap"
About this Quote
“Life has become very cheap” is the kind of moral inflation claim that politicians love because it turns a policy argument into a cultural diagnosis. Robert Casey isn’t just opposing abortion rights; he’s sketching a story about national decline, where a legal framework (“abortion on demand”) supposedly remakes the emotional weather of the country. The phrasing does two strategic things at once: it sidesteps the messy particulars of pregnancy by elevating the stakes to civilization-level consequence, and it casts the speaker as a sober judge (“in my judgment”) rather than a partisan combatant.
The intent is to reframe abortion from a question of autonomy and medical care into a referendum on what the nation values. “On demand” is doing a lot of work: it implies casualness, consumer entitlement, and moral frivolity, a rhetorical move that nudges the listener to imagine the decision as impulsive rather than complex. Then “environment” broadens the charge. It’s not merely that abortions occur; it’s that the permission corrodes society, making violence, neglect, or indifference more likely. That’s a slippery claim by design: hard to measure, easy to feel.
Context matters. Casey, a prominent Democratic governor in a party moving toward abortion rights orthodoxy, often used this language to claim moral seriousness without sounding like the religious right. He positions himself as the responsible dissenter: still modern, still public-minded, but unwilling to accept what he frames as a cultural bargain where compassion for women is purchased by numbing the public conscience. The line works because it’s an accusation that doesn’t need proof; it recruits anxiety as evidence.
The intent is to reframe abortion from a question of autonomy and medical care into a referendum on what the nation values. “On demand” is doing a lot of work: it implies casualness, consumer entitlement, and moral frivolity, a rhetorical move that nudges the listener to imagine the decision as impulsive rather than complex. Then “environment” broadens the charge. It’s not merely that abortions occur; it’s that the permission corrodes society, making violence, neglect, or indifference more likely. That’s a slippery claim by design: hard to measure, easy to feel.
Context matters. Casey, a prominent Democratic governor in a party moving toward abortion rights orthodoxy, often used this language to claim moral seriousness without sounding like the religious right. He positions himself as the responsible dissenter: still modern, still public-minded, but unwilling to accept what he frames as a cultural bargain where compassion for women is purchased by numbing the public conscience. The line works because it’s an accusation that doesn’t need proof; it recruits anxiety as evidence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List

