"Abstraction is everybody's zero but nobody's nought"
About this Quote
Smithson’s line snaps like a paradox you can carry in your pocket: abstraction is “everybody’s zero” but “nobody’s nought.” The move is slyly mathematical, but it’s really about ownership and emptiness. “Zero” is a shared tool, a baseline value anyone can plug into an equation. It’s practical, portable, and socially agreed-upon. “Nought,” by contrast, is zero with a philosophical hangover: not just absence, but negation, a void that threatens to swallow meaning. Smithson is diagnosing how abstraction gets normalized in modern culture - usable, even fashionable - while its more destabilizing implications are quietly refused.
The phrasing matters. “Everybody’s” makes abstraction sound democratic, even inevitable: a common language of modernism, from painting to architecture to design. Yet “nobody’s” exposes the dodge: people want the clean look of reduction without confronting what reduction implies about value, self, and world. Abstraction becomes a zero you can possess (a style, a signature, a market category) rather than a nought that possesses you (a confrontation with nothingness, entropy, collapse).
That subtext sits neatly inside Smithson’s broader project. As a land artist obsessed with geology, ruin, and “entropy,” he treated meaning as something that erodes. In that context, abstraction isn’t transcendence; it’s a cultural technology for making emptiness feel stable. The quote needles modernism’s confidence: the void has been domesticated into a number, while the real void - the kind that can’t be framed, sold, or resolved - remains unclaimed.
The phrasing matters. “Everybody’s” makes abstraction sound democratic, even inevitable: a common language of modernism, from painting to architecture to design. Yet “nobody’s” exposes the dodge: people want the clean look of reduction without confronting what reduction implies about value, self, and world. Abstraction becomes a zero you can possess (a style, a signature, a market category) rather than a nought that possesses you (a confrontation with nothingness, entropy, collapse).
That subtext sits neatly inside Smithson’s broader project. As a land artist obsessed with geology, ruin, and “entropy,” he treated meaning as something that erodes. In that context, abstraction isn’t transcendence; it’s a cultural technology for making emptiness feel stable. The quote needles modernism’s confidence: the void has been domesticated into a number, while the real void - the kind that can’t be framed, sold, or resolved - remains unclaimed.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List






