"Accidents will happen in the best regulated families"
About this Quote
A tidy little sentence that smuggles chaos into the parlor. "Accidents will happen in the best regulated families" sounds like reassurance, but it lands as a quiet indictment of the very idea that life can be fully managed. The phrase "best regulated" is doing the real work: it invokes the bourgeois faith in order, schedules, propriety, the household as a well-run machine. Dos Passos, a novelist allergic to sentimental myths about American stability, threads a pin through that balloon.
The intent isn’t to excuse wrongdoing so much as to expose how quickly respectability becomes a shield. By framing misfortune as inevitable, the line offers cover: if accidents are guaranteed even in exemplary homes, then the mess doesn’t have to mean anything. It’s a social alibi, a way to keep the family’s public story intact. At the same time, the sentence has a democratic sting. “Best” implies a hierarchy of households, and Dos Passos undercuts it: the forces that bruise and break people don’t check credentials.
The subtext is almost journalistic, which fits Dos Passos’s modernist eye for systems. Families aren’t just private havens; they’re institutions with rules, roles, and pressure points. Accidents can be literal mishaps, but they also read as the sudden exposures - affairs, violence, poverty, addiction - that “regulation” tries to keep offstage. The line works because it’s compact, commonsensical, and faintly patronizing, like advice offered over a teacup while the house smolders behind the curtain.
The intent isn’t to excuse wrongdoing so much as to expose how quickly respectability becomes a shield. By framing misfortune as inevitable, the line offers cover: if accidents are guaranteed even in exemplary homes, then the mess doesn’t have to mean anything. It’s a social alibi, a way to keep the family’s public story intact. At the same time, the sentence has a democratic sting. “Best” implies a hierarchy of households, and Dos Passos undercuts it: the forces that bruise and break people don’t check credentials.
The subtext is almost journalistic, which fits Dos Passos’s modernist eye for systems. Families aren’t just private havens; they’re institutions with rules, roles, and pressure points. Accidents can be literal mishaps, but they also read as the sudden exposures - affairs, violence, poverty, addiction - that “regulation” tries to keep offstage. The line works because it’s compact, commonsensical, and faintly patronizing, like advice offered over a teacup while the house smolders behind the curtain.
Quote Details
| Topic | Family |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by John
Add to List





