"Activities that seem to represent choices are often inert reproductions of accepted practice"
About this Quote
Choice is the signature aesthetic of modern life: menus, settings, “personalization,” endless toggles that flatter us with agency. Zuboff punctures that comfort by insisting that much of what passes for choice is choreography. “Activities that seem to represent choices” points to the everyday gestures we perform as evidence of autonomy - clicking, consenting, selecting - while the range of possible action has already been pre-shaped by institutions, platforms, and norms. The sting is in “inert reproductions”: these aren’t merely conventional decisions, they’re lifeless repetitions, habits mistaken for freedom.
Her intent is diagnostic, almost clinical. Zuboff isn’t scolding individuals for being sheep; she’s describing a system that manufactures the feeling of self-direction while routing behavior into predictable channels. The subtext is that power has gotten quieter. Instead of commands, we get defaults. Instead of coercion, we get frictionless “best practices” that we internalize until they feel like our own preferences.
Context matters: Zuboff’s work on surveillance capitalism and the datafied economy is obsessed with how contemporary power operates through behavioral extraction and nudging rather than overt force. In that world, “accepted practice” is not neutral tradition; it’s often a business model, a bureaucratic requirement, a design pattern optimized to capture attention, compliance, or data. The quote works because it names the uncanny gap many people sense: the more interfaces promise empowerment, the more our actions start to look the same. Freedom becomes a performance staged inside someone else’s script.
Her intent is diagnostic, almost clinical. Zuboff isn’t scolding individuals for being sheep; she’s describing a system that manufactures the feeling of self-direction while routing behavior into predictable channels. The subtext is that power has gotten quieter. Instead of commands, we get defaults. Instead of coercion, we get frictionless “best practices” that we internalize until they feel like our own preferences.
Context matters: Zuboff’s work on surveillance capitalism and the datafied economy is obsessed with how contemporary power operates through behavioral extraction and nudging rather than overt force. In that world, “accepted practice” is not neutral tradition; it’s often a business model, a bureaucratic requirement, a design pattern optimized to capture attention, compliance, or data. The quote works because it names the uncanny gap many people sense: the more interfaces promise empowerment, the more our actions start to look the same. Freedom becomes a performance staged inside someone else’s script.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by Shoshana
Add to List
