"After all, we didn't bring democracy to Germany in 1945; Hitler destroyed democracy there first"
About this Quote
Scowcroft is doing what seasoned national security hands do best: puncturing a feel-good story before it hardens into doctrine. The line rejects the comforting American myth that U.S. power is primarily an export business for freedom. Instead, it insists on a harsher chronology: Germany had a democracy, and it was Germany, through Hitler and the Nazi seizure of the state, that annihilated it. By 1945, the Allies weren’t “delivering” democracy so much as dismantling a regime that had already burned its own constitutional order to the ground.
The intent is corrective, but the subtext is strategic. If you misremember 1945 as a simple case of America installing democracy by force, you’re more likely to reach for that template elsewhere and underestimate how contingent postwar Germany really was: total military defeat, exhaustive occupation, a discredited elite, an exhausted population, and the looming Soviet threat that helped anchor West Germany to the West. Scowcroft’s phrasing quietly moves credit away from American virtue and toward circumstances and institutions: democracy is easier to rebuild where it once existed, and where society has been jolted into accepting new rules.
Context matters: Scowcroft, a cautious realist shaped by Vietnam and the Cold War, is warning against moral triumphalism masquerading as history. He’s also reminding audiences that democratic collapse often comes from within. The uncomfortable implication isn’t just about foreign policy hubris; it’s that democracies don’t need invaders to die. They can be strangled by their own leaders, legally, step by step.
The intent is corrective, but the subtext is strategic. If you misremember 1945 as a simple case of America installing democracy by force, you’re more likely to reach for that template elsewhere and underestimate how contingent postwar Germany really was: total military defeat, exhaustive occupation, a discredited elite, an exhausted population, and the looming Soviet threat that helped anchor West Germany to the West. Scowcroft’s phrasing quietly moves credit away from American virtue and toward circumstances and institutions: democracy is easier to rebuild where it once existed, and where society has been jolted into accepting new rules.
Context matters: Scowcroft, a cautious realist shaped by Vietnam and the Cold War, is warning against moral triumphalism masquerading as history. He’s also reminding audiences that democratic collapse often comes from within. The uncomfortable implication isn’t just about foreign policy hubris; it’s that democracies don’t need invaders to die. They can be strangled by their own leaders, legally, step by step.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by Brent
Add to List






