"All bad poetry springs from genuine feeling"
About this Quote
Wilde lobs this line like a jeweled grenade: it detonates the piety that treats sincerity as art’s highest credential. Coming from a dramatist who made a career out of epigrams, masks, and performed identity, the target is clear. “Genuine feeling” is not condemned because emotion is worthless, but because unshaped emotion is lazy. Bad poetry, in Wilde’s view, is often the diary page dressed up as literature: the writer mistakes intensity for craft and assumes the reader owes them reverence for having felt something deeply.
The subtext is Wilde’s favorite provocation: art isn’t therapy. It’s construction. Feeling may be the raw material, but without form, wit, and discipline it curdles into sentimentality, that Victorian parlor currency Wilde loved to counterfeit and expose. By pinning bad poetry on “genuine feeling,” he’s also taking a swipe at moral earnestness, the era’s habit of confusing virtue with value. The most dangerous artistic stance isn’t cynicism; it’s the unexamined belief that authenticity alone guarantees meaning.
Context matters: late-19th-century Britain was obsessed with respectability and uplift, and Wilde’s aestheticism was a deliberate counter-program. He’s defending artifice as a moral act of its own, because it requires distance, selection, and restraint. The sting is that “genuine feeling” can be a kind of tyranny - it pressures the artist to confess rather than compose, and pressures the audience to applaud the confession. Wilde’s line rescues art from the demand to be earnest, insisting it earn its effects the hard way: through making.
The subtext is Wilde’s favorite provocation: art isn’t therapy. It’s construction. Feeling may be the raw material, but without form, wit, and discipline it curdles into sentimentality, that Victorian parlor currency Wilde loved to counterfeit and expose. By pinning bad poetry on “genuine feeling,” he’s also taking a swipe at moral earnestness, the era’s habit of confusing virtue with value. The most dangerous artistic stance isn’t cynicism; it’s the unexamined belief that authenticity alone guarantees meaning.
Context matters: late-19th-century Britain was obsessed with respectability and uplift, and Wilde’s aestheticism was a deliberate counter-program. He’s defending artifice as a moral act of its own, because it requires distance, selection, and restraint. The sting is that “genuine feeling” can be a kind of tyranny - it pressures the artist to confess rather than compose, and pressures the audience to applaud the confession. Wilde’s line rescues art from the demand to be earnest, insisting it earn its effects the hard way: through making.
Quote Details
| Topic | Poetry |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Oscar
Add to List







