"All compromise is based on give and take, but there can be no give and take on fundamentals. Any compromise on mere fundamentals is a surrender. For it is all give and no take"
About this Quote
Compromise is usually sold as maturity: the adult choice, the reasonable middle. Gandhi flips that comfort on its head by drawing a hard border around "fundamentals" and daring you to cross it. The line works because it sounds like plain common sense - give and take - then quietly turns into a moral trap. If a principle is truly foundational, you cannot bargain with it without changing what you are. The rhetoric is almost mathematical: compromise requires symmetry; fundamentals, by definition, allow none. So the person urging you to "meet halfway" may not be preaching peace at all, but asking for your capitulation dressed up as pragmatism.
The subtext is strategic as much as spiritual. Gandhi is defending an ethic of nonviolence and truth (satyagraha) that can look, from the outside, like pliability. This quote insists on the opposite: nonviolence is not passivity, and negotiation is not the same as moral concession. In colonial India, British authorities could offer reforms, advisory councils, incremental autonomy - deals that sounded like progress while leaving the core structure of domination intact. Gandhi names that move: a compromise that preserves the central injustice is "all give and no take."
Its power also lies in how it polices language. "Fundamentals" is the key word, slippery enough to invite abuse, yet urgent enough to rally a movement. Gandhi is warning followers not to confuse tactical flexibility with ethical drift - and warning opponents that certain demands are not bargaining chips.
The subtext is strategic as much as spiritual. Gandhi is defending an ethic of nonviolence and truth (satyagraha) that can look, from the outside, like pliability. This quote insists on the opposite: nonviolence is not passivity, and negotiation is not the same as moral concession. In colonial India, British authorities could offer reforms, advisory councils, incremental autonomy - deals that sounded like progress while leaving the core structure of domination intact. Gandhi names that move: a compromise that preserves the central injustice is "all give and no take."
Its power also lies in how it polices language. "Fundamentals" is the key word, slippery enough to invite abuse, yet urgent enough to rally a movement. Gandhi is warning followers not to confuse tactical flexibility with ethical drift - and warning opponents that certain demands are not bargaining chips.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Mahatma
Add to List





