"All human wisdom works and has worries and grief as reward"
About this Quote
Human “wisdom,” Hamann suggests, is a kind of labor that pays out in the wrong currency. Not serenity, not mastery, but work, worry, and grief. The line bites because it flips the Enlightenment’s favorite promise: that reason polishes the world into something legible and therefore controllable. Hamann, the anti-system philosopher who distrusted neat rational programs, treats wisdom less like a ladder to certainty and more like a contract you sign without reading the fine print.
The phrasing is deceptively plain. “Works” makes wisdom sound like a tool - practical, productive, even virtuous. Then the “reward” arrives: anxieties and sorrows that feel like side effects, except Hamann frames them as the actual payoff. Subtext: if you see more clearly, you don’t float above human vulnerability; you notice it everywhere, including in yourself. Intelligence sharpens the edges. The wise person doesn’t escape the world’s contingency and suffering; they become newly accountable to it.
Context matters. Writing in the late 18th century, Hamann was pushing back against an era intoxicated with rational progress, universal method, and the idea that knowledge can be cleaned of mystery, faith, and particularity. His critique isn’t anti-thinking so much as anti-hubris: “human” wisdom, bounded and fallible, can’t redeem us from the human condition. It can only deepen our awareness of it.
What makes the line work is its moral trapdoor. It denies the reader the comforting fantasy that insight is self-help. If wisdom is honest, it costs you - and that cost may be the only proof you’ve actually acquired it.
The phrasing is deceptively plain. “Works” makes wisdom sound like a tool - practical, productive, even virtuous. Then the “reward” arrives: anxieties and sorrows that feel like side effects, except Hamann frames them as the actual payoff. Subtext: if you see more clearly, you don’t float above human vulnerability; you notice it everywhere, including in yourself. Intelligence sharpens the edges. The wise person doesn’t escape the world’s contingency and suffering; they become newly accountable to it.
Context matters. Writing in the late 18th century, Hamann was pushing back against an era intoxicated with rational progress, universal method, and the idea that knowledge can be cleaned of mystery, faith, and particularity. His critique isn’t anti-thinking so much as anti-hubris: “human” wisdom, bounded and fallible, can’t redeem us from the human condition. It can only deepen our awareness of it.
What makes the line work is its moral trapdoor. It denies the reader the comforting fantasy that insight is self-help. If wisdom is honest, it costs you - and that cost may be the only proof you’ve actually acquired it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Johann
Add to List











