"All intelligent thoughts have already been thought; what is necessary is only to try to think them again"
About this Quote
Goethe’s line lands like a provocation disguised as humility: if every “intelligent” thought has already occurred, originality isn’t a lightning bolt but a discipline. He’s not dismissing creativity so much as demoting the ego. The sentence quietly attacks a romantic fantasy he helped popularize elsewhere: the lone genius inventing the world from scratch. Here, genius looks less like invention than like re-encounter.
The subtext is almost pedagogical. “To try to think them again” isn’t rote repetition; it’s reenactment. An idea doesn’t really become yours when you can quote it, but when you can reconstruct it under pressure, with your own stakes and blind spots. Goethe is pointing at the difference between borrowed intelligence and lived intelligence. The verb “try” matters: the task is strenuous, imperfect, and ongoing. Thinking is work, not a posture.
Context sharpens the intent. Goethe wrote in a culture saturated with classical models, translation, and reworking - where modernity was being assembled from old forms. Post-Enlightenment Europe was obsessively cataloging knowledge while also accelerating change; it makes sense to insist that progress depends on metabolizing inherited thought rather than fetishizing novelty. There’s also a warning shot at fashionable opinion: if you haven’t fought your way back to the insight, you’re just wearing it.
In an era that rewards “new takes,” Goethe’s sentence reads as an antidote: the real flex is not having an opinion, but earning it.
The subtext is almost pedagogical. “To try to think them again” isn’t rote repetition; it’s reenactment. An idea doesn’t really become yours when you can quote it, but when you can reconstruct it under pressure, with your own stakes and blind spots. Goethe is pointing at the difference between borrowed intelligence and lived intelligence. The verb “try” matters: the task is strenuous, imperfect, and ongoing. Thinking is work, not a posture.
Context sharpens the intent. Goethe wrote in a culture saturated with classical models, translation, and reworking - where modernity was being assembled from old forms. Post-Enlightenment Europe was obsessively cataloging knowledge while also accelerating change; it makes sense to insist that progress depends on metabolizing inherited thought rather than fetishizing novelty. There’s also a warning shot at fashionable opinion: if you haven’t fought your way back to the insight, you’re just wearing it.
In an era that rewards “new takes,” Goethe’s sentence reads as an antidote: the real flex is not having an opinion, but earning it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Johann Wolfgang von Goethe — German aphorism: "Alle klugen Gedanken sind schon gedacht; man muss sie nur noch einmal denken." Commonly cited in collections of his aphorisms (e.g., Maxims and Reflections). |
More Quotes by Johann
Add to List









