"All men think that all men are mortal but themselves"
About this Quote
Immortality is always someone else’s problem. Edward Young’s line skewers a mental dodge so ordinary we barely notice it: we can recite mortality as a fact, even wield it as wisdom, yet keep our own death filed under “later,” an abstract event that happens to other bodies. The sting comes from the grammatical pivot - “all men” collapses into “but themselves” - exposing how easily the mind grants itself special exemption while pretending to speak in universal truths.
Young writes as an 18th-century poet steeped in Christian moral urgency, and the quote carries that devotional pressure. This isn’t a neutral observation about psychology; it’s an indictment. The subtext is theological as much as philosophical: if you truly believed you were mortal, you’d live differently - with humility, with restraint, with attention to judgment, time, and consequence. Denial becomes a form of vanity, a quiet rebellion against limits.
It also works because it targets the self as a rhetorical blind spot. We can think about death statistically, socially, even poetically; we struggle to imagine our own nonexistence without turning it into a story in which we’re still the viewer. Young weaponizes that contradiction. In an era of Enlightenment confidence and expanding public life, the line functions like a pin to the balloon: progress doesn’t cancel finitude, and reason doesn’t cure self-deception. Mortality, he implies, is the one truth that turns sincerity into action.
Young writes as an 18th-century poet steeped in Christian moral urgency, and the quote carries that devotional pressure. This isn’t a neutral observation about psychology; it’s an indictment. The subtext is theological as much as philosophical: if you truly believed you were mortal, you’d live differently - with humility, with restraint, with attention to judgment, time, and consequence. Denial becomes a form of vanity, a quiet rebellion against limits.
It also works because it targets the self as a rhetorical blind spot. We can think about death statistically, socially, even poetically; we struggle to imagine our own nonexistence without turning it into a story in which we’re still the viewer. Young weaponizes that contradiction. In an era of Enlightenment confidence and expanding public life, the line functions like a pin to the balloon: progress doesn’t cancel finitude, and reason doesn’t cure self-deception. Mortality, he implies, is the one truth that turns sincerity into action.
Quote Details
| Topic | Mortality |
|---|---|
| Source | Edward Young, Night-Thoughts (The Complaint: or Night-Thoughts on Life, Death & Immortality), 1742–1745 — contains line 'All men think that all men are mortal but themselves'. |
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List









