"All objects, all phases of culture are alive. They have voices. They speak of their history and interrelatedness. And they are all talking at once!"
About this Quote
Paglia turns the museum into a nightclub: everything has a mic, and nobody waits their turn. The line is animated, almost combative, pushing back against the tidy idea that culture can be filed into silent categories (fine art here, pop trash there; “important” history in one wing, disposable style in another). Her intent is less mystical than it sounds. “Alive” is a dare to treat objects as agents, not props: a painting, a shoe, a porn still, a cathedral buttress all exert force, carry residues, and keep arguing with the present.
The subtext is classic Paglia: impatience with academic gatekeeping and with the critic’s fantasy of neutral distance. If every object “speaks,” the interpreter isn’t a priest decoding a sacred text; they’re an eavesdropper in a crowded room, trying to catch patterns in the noise. “Interrelatedness” is the tell. She’s insisting that influences leak across borders - sex into religion, commerce into aesthetics, antiquity into MTV - and that the critic’s job is to hear those contaminations rather than sanitizing them.
Context matters. Paglia emerged as a high-voltage contrarian in late-20th-century culture wars, skeptical of theory that flattens art into ideology alone. This quote is her alternative method in miniature: a maximalist, sensuous formalism that treats history as a living system, not a timeline. “All talking at once” also warns against our hunger for single-cause explanations. Culture is polyphonic. Any reading that makes it orderly is, to Paglia, already a kind of censorship.
The subtext is classic Paglia: impatience with academic gatekeeping and with the critic’s fantasy of neutral distance. If every object “speaks,” the interpreter isn’t a priest decoding a sacred text; they’re an eavesdropper in a crowded room, trying to catch patterns in the noise. “Interrelatedness” is the tell. She’s insisting that influences leak across borders - sex into religion, commerce into aesthetics, antiquity into MTV - and that the critic’s job is to hear those contaminations rather than sanitizing them.
Context matters. Paglia emerged as a high-voltage contrarian in late-20th-century culture wars, skeptical of theory that flattens art into ideology alone. This quote is her alternative method in miniature: a maximalist, sensuous formalism that treats history as a living system, not a timeline. “All talking at once” also warns against our hunger for single-cause explanations. Culture is polyphonic. Any reading that makes it orderly is, to Paglia, already a kind of censorship.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Camille
Add to List
