"All our discontents about what we want appeared to spring from the want of thankfulness for what we have"
About this Quote
Defoe aims a scalpel at a familiar modern ailment: dissatisfaction that multiplies the moment desire becomes a lifestyle. The line pivots on a pun that does real work - “want” as craving and “want” as lack. By yoking them, he implies discontent isn’t just about not having enough; it’s about cultivating a mental posture of insufficiency. The cure he offers, “thankfulness,” isn’t soft sentiment. It’s a discipline that interrupts the economy of perpetual wanting.
The phrasing is also a journalist’s move: “appeared to spring from” reads like reported observation rather than sermon. Defoe doesn’t thunder about sin; he diagnoses a pattern, as if he’s watched people (or a nation) talk themselves into misery by keeping their eyes trained on the next acquisition, promotion, or status marker. That small rhetorical hedge makes the argument more persuasive because it invites assent without demanding it.
Context matters. Defoe wrote in an England being reshaped by trade, credit, colonial expansion, and early consumer culture - a world where aspiration was newly democratized and newly weaponized. In that environment, gratitude becomes a countercultural technology: not passive acceptance, but resistance to a system that profits when you feel perpetually behind. The subtext is bracing: if you can’t locate satisfaction in what you already possess, getting more won’t fix you. It will only refine your unhappiness.
The phrasing is also a journalist’s move: “appeared to spring from” reads like reported observation rather than sermon. Defoe doesn’t thunder about sin; he diagnoses a pattern, as if he’s watched people (or a nation) talk themselves into misery by keeping their eyes trained on the next acquisition, promotion, or status marker. That small rhetorical hedge makes the argument more persuasive because it invites assent without demanding it.
Context matters. Defoe wrote in an England being reshaped by trade, credit, colonial expansion, and early consumer culture - a world where aspiration was newly democratized and newly weaponized. In that environment, gratitude becomes a countercultural technology: not passive acceptance, but resistance to a system that profits when you feel perpetually behind. The subtext is bracing: if you can’t locate satisfaction in what you already possess, getting more won’t fix you. It will only refine your unhappiness.
Quote Details
| Topic | Gratitude |
|---|---|
| Source | Robinson Crusoe (novel), Daniel Defoe, 1719. |
More Quotes by Daniel
Add to List










