"All pitchers are born pitchers"
About this Quote
DiMaggio’s line has the clean, locker-room certainty of a man who spent his life watching talent get mythologized. “All pitchers are born pitchers” isn’t a scouting report; it’s a cultural argument about baseball’s most fetishized position. Hitting can look like craft - hours in the cage, a swing rebuilt. Pitching, in the popular imagination, reads like fate: an arm you’re handed at birth, a body built to throw violence with precision.
The intent is partly reverence, partly boundary-drawing. Pitchers are different, DiMaggio implies, and the difference isn’t just training. It’s temperament: the solitude of the mound, the willingness to fail publicly every few minutes, the nerve to throw the same pitch again after it gets punished. By framing pitchers as “born,” he flatters the mystique of the role while quietly absolving everyone else - if you can’t do it, it wasn’t your fault. That’s a comforting story in a sport obsessed with measuring, ranking, and assigning destiny.
In context, DiMaggio comes from an era that loved natural gifts and distrusted over-explanation. Long before biomechanics labs and PitchFX dashboards, baseball explained excellence with essence: “good hands,” “a live arm,” “ice water in the veins.” The subtext is pre-analytics and deeply human: we prefer heroes who seem inevitable. DiMaggio isn’t denying work; he’s naming the romance fans and players keep reaching for - that some roles choose you, and that’s what makes them sacred.
The intent is partly reverence, partly boundary-drawing. Pitchers are different, DiMaggio implies, and the difference isn’t just training. It’s temperament: the solitude of the mound, the willingness to fail publicly every few minutes, the nerve to throw the same pitch again after it gets punished. By framing pitchers as “born,” he flatters the mystique of the role while quietly absolving everyone else - if you can’t do it, it wasn’t your fault. That’s a comforting story in a sport obsessed with measuring, ranking, and assigning destiny.
In context, DiMaggio comes from an era that loved natural gifts and distrusted over-explanation. Long before biomechanics labs and PitchFX dashboards, baseball explained excellence with essence: “good hands,” “a live arm,” “ice water in the veins.” The subtext is pre-analytics and deeply human: we prefer heroes who seem inevitable. DiMaggio isn’t denying work; he’s naming the romance fans and players keep reaching for - that some roles choose you, and that’s what makes them sacred.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sports |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Joe
Add to List




