"All religions have based morality on obedience, that is to say, on voluntary slavery. That is why they have always been more pernicious than any political organization. For the latter makes use of violence, the former - of the corruption of the will"
About this Quote
Herzen isn`t merely taking a swing at religion; he`s indicting a particular technology of power: the kind that recruits its subjects as co-authors of their own submission. The bite in "voluntary slavery" is deliberate. Political regimes can coerce you into compliance, but religions, as he frames them, coax you into calling compliance virtue. Obedience stops being a tactic for survival and becomes the moral ideal itself. That reversal is the trick, and Herzen wants you to feel how total it is.
The provocation that religion is "more pernicious than any political organization" rests on a sharp psychological hierarchy. Violence bruises the body, makes martyrs, creates clear antagonists. Corrupting the will is subtler: it rearranges your inner life so that domination reads as duty, and doubt reads as sin. If the state takes your freedom, you know you`ve lost something; if a church persuades you to surrender it, you may experience the loss as spiritual gain. That is what makes it harder to revolt.
Context matters. Herzen was a 19th-century Russian exile and radical watching autocracy and Orthodoxy braid themselves into a single apparatus of legitimacy. The Russian state didn`t just police; it sanctified. His language reflects a broader European revolt against throne-and-altar politics, but also a journalist`s impatience with metaphysical cover stories. The subtext is almost tactical: revolutions fail when they fight only the baton and not the belief system that makes the baton feel deserved.
The provocation that religion is "more pernicious than any political organization" rests on a sharp psychological hierarchy. Violence bruises the body, makes martyrs, creates clear antagonists. Corrupting the will is subtler: it rearranges your inner life so that domination reads as duty, and doubt reads as sin. If the state takes your freedom, you know you`ve lost something; if a church persuades you to surrender it, you may experience the loss as spiritual gain. That is what makes it harder to revolt.
Context matters. Herzen was a 19th-century Russian exile and radical watching autocracy and Orthodoxy braid themselves into a single apparatus of legitimacy. The Russian state didn`t just police; it sanctified. His language reflects a broader European revolt against throne-and-altar politics, but also a journalist`s impatience with metaphysical cover stories. The subtext is almost tactical: revolutions fail when they fight only the baton and not the belief system that makes the baton feel deserved.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Alexander
Add to List
