"All... religions show the same disparity between belief and practice, and each is safe till it tries to exclude the rest"
About this Quote
A politician’s tolerance is rarely abstract; it’s a survival strategy dressed as principle. Wentworth’s line cuts with the cool pragmatism of someone who has watched faith serve as both moral vocabulary and political weapon. By noting the “disparity between belief and practice,” he punctures the pious self-image every confession prefers: doctrine is clean, institutions are not. The move is disarming because it doesn’t single out one sect for hypocrisy; it levels the charge across “all... religions,” turning scandal into a constant of human governance rather than a partisan insult.
The second clause is the real payload: “each is safe till it tries to exclude the rest.” Safety here isn’t spiritual security; it’s social stability. Wentworth implies that a religion can coexist with the state, even benefit from its protection, as long as it doesn’t demand monopoly. The moment it seeks to “exclude,” it stops being mere belief and becomes a bid for coercive power, triggering resistance, backlash, and the cycle of repression that makes everyone less safe.
Context matters: early Stuart England was a pressure cooker of competing Protestant identities, anti-Catholic paranoia, and a monarchy struggling to manage religious conformity without igniting revolt. Wentworth (Strafford) lived inside that knot of crown, Parliament, and church. The subtext reads like a warning to zealots and rulers alike: persecution isn’t conviction’s proof; it’s the spark that turns theology into civil conflict.
The second clause is the real payload: “each is safe till it tries to exclude the rest.” Safety here isn’t spiritual security; it’s social stability. Wentworth implies that a religion can coexist with the state, even benefit from its protection, as long as it doesn’t demand monopoly. The moment it seeks to “exclude,” it stops being mere belief and becomes a bid for coercive power, triggering resistance, backlash, and the cycle of repression that makes everyone less safe.
Context matters: early Stuart England was a pressure cooker of competing Protestant identities, anti-Catholic paranoia, and a monarchy struggling to manage religious conformity without igniting revolt. Wentworth (Strafford) lived inside that knot of crown, Parliament, and church. The subtext reads like a warning to zealots and rulers alike: persecution isn’t conviction’s proof; it’s the spark that turns theology into civil conflict.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Thomas
Add to List




